|
|
|
Man you have a hell of a car collection! I've always liked the Panhard 24. Stunning looking things, and neat to learn about their engines a little more. I wonder if torsion bar valve springs means there's lower reciprocating weight... The Panhard engines are nice, though. Successful racing engines in their class, in their day. So twinny? How ambitious are you feeling? Weld two panhard twins together to make a flat 4? Mr Millyard makes it look easy Thanks! Indeed the torsion bar setup reduces the weight involved in the movement and as such can therefore sustain higher speeds without valve lift. Also, the torsion bar is sort of shared between the two valves; meaning the one opening is also pushing the other valve closed. That combined with some hydraulic compensation for valve clearance makes it a very tricky engine to do a valve adjustment on. Panhard did work on a X layout of two twins together with a crankshaft somewhat similar to a rotation engine like on old airplanes. But just the twin is tricky enough as is...
|
|
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
|
|
|
|
[quote author=" engineer " source=" Now I have a 2-cilinder and 4-ciinder Boxer. I'm also quite a fan of early model Corvair so maybe some day I will add a 6-cilinder Boxer also. I am beginning to think we have some similar tastes with cars I looked at the Panhard before you bought it, maybe I should have done more research but glad to see it has gone to a good home. A Corvair is still on my bucket list if the right one turns up at the right price ( doubtful these days ) Plus I have had a couple of Karmann Ghias [/quote] Some similarities come in mind. I do like the air-cooled VW's but as price-wise they are overrated and my wife does not like the Beetle I don't think that will happen. A German friend of mine always wanted a Beetle but only got one when he moved to Sweden - only place where pricing is normal.
|
|
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
|
|
Jan 10, 2023 15:24:22 GMT
|
You have a couple more to choose from. The Steyr 500 is already mentioned, but there was also a 126 based version ( very rare ). The BMW700, and early Daf's. All flat aircooled 2 cyls... There were some aircooled flat 4 Tatra's. The Jowett Javelin, Subaru of course, Goliath, and the Lancia Flavia had watercooled flat 4 engines. Pretty sure there was a watercooled flat 6 Subaru as well. You could build a really unique collection... ( although your collection is pretty unique already... )
|
|
|
|
|
|
Jan 10, 2023 15:46:22 GMT
|
You have a couple more to choose from. The Steyr 500 is already mentioned, but there was also a 126 based version ( very rare ). The BMW700, and early Daf's. All flat aircooled 2 cyls... There were some aircooled flat 4 Tatra's. The Jowett Javelin, Subaru of course, Goliath, and the Lancia Flavia had watercooled flat 4 engines. Pretty sure there was a watercooled flat 6 Subaru as well. You could build a really unique collection... ( although your collection is pretty unique already... ) Lancia Gamma had a bored out 2.5l flat 4 from the Flavia (I believe, don't think it's a clean sheet design). My dad had a coupe that a tree squished in the 87 storm. Citroen GS. I wonder how much a 512BB is going for these days...
|
|
|
|
|
|
Jan 10, 2023 15:52:30 GMT
|
You have a couple more to choose from. The Steyr 500 is already mentioned, but there was also a 126 based version ( very rare ). The BMW700, and early Daf's. All flat aircooled 2 cyls... There were some aircooled flat 4 Tatra's. The Jowett Javelin, Subaru of course, Goliath, and the Lancia Flavia had watercooled flat 4 engines. Pretty sure there was a watercooled flat 6 Subaru as well. You could build a really unique collection... ( although your collection is pretty unique already... ) Lancia Gamma had a bored out 2.5l flat 4 from the Flavia (I believe, don't think it's a clean sheet design). My dad had a coupe that a tree squished in the 87 storm. Citroen GS. I wonder how much a 512BB is going for these days... Forgot about the GS ( and the Ami Super.. )
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Even Toyota build a flat-twin in a few domestic market models. A BMW 700 would fit to the collection also. The garage owner where my classic cars are kept running owns the Subaru SVX and XT - at least one of those is a 6-cilinder. Also a Gamma Coupe BTW. Plenty of Boxer engines around really. I would not mind a 512BB but that one is in the price range of "would not enjoy driving it out of fear for financial crisis" Anyway: the Sud now has its own thread: forum.retro-rides.org/thread/223891/1975-alfasud-resist
|
|
Last Edit: Jan 11, 2023 9:07:56 GMT by engineer
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
jamesd1972
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 2,921
Club RR Member Number: 40
|
|
Jan 11, 2023 14:05:25 GMT
|
One I spotted in France a few years ago. Old boy had owned from new and seamed happy that the strange Englishman knew what it was and liked it. He showed us under the bonnet but didn't grab a photo. Lovely different cars. Keep the updates coming. James
|
|
|
|
|
|
Feb 27, 2023 13:59:36 GMT
|
My Panhard has rubber as a floor covering. Not bad but I like carpet or floor mats better. Via the Panhard club I learned of a webshop that sells floormats and carpets for many classic cars, mainly French ones as that is where they are based. And they even had one for a 24 Berline. This weekend it was time to place it. This one is a actual carpet so seats, seatbelts and rearbench had to come out. Now, I have recently spoken to a previous owner that had it from late 70s to mid 90s. Actually the guy that brought it over from Northern France. One of the new things I learned is that the entire cabin floor has been replaced to take care of rust. So the carpet fits quite well but not perfect. That maybe on the carpet or on the inaccuracies of the floor. Either way it is good enough, just not perfect. Much of an improvement in looks, feel and probably sound dampening as well. The Panhard's startermotor was a bit slow at first attempt (just like last year) but then got the engine started just fine. Brakes were a little stuck but came free with a little engine torque. Rev counter repair attempt did not work however. And it needed a wash While working on it a couple of people on the street approached me. I got guesses from NSU, BMW and even Simca... none of them ever had heard from a Panhard however
|
|
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
|
|
May 16, 2023 13:54:14 GMT
|
|
|
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
|
|
May 16, 2023 14:01:17 GMT
|
And the Panhard made it to another fun event. A brief mention by mr. Hubnut. I took the Panhard together with my AlfaSud there. Both gathered a lot of attention. I did manage to break one of my keys so new spares are needed. Also the startermotor is a little slow.
|
|
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
|
The Doctor
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 3,449
Club RR Member Number: 48
|
|
May 16, 2023 15:06:00 GMT
|
I didn't realise it was your Panhard at EMWalhalla! Was a good day.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The Panhard got a good clean and had a task to do as a wedding car. Not for us but for a friend. Such a task suits it. It's very elegant and a bit unusual.
|
|
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
|
|
|
Man you have a hell of a car collection! I've always liked the Panhard 24. Stunning looking things, and neat to learn about their engines a little more. I wonder if torsion bar valve springs means there's lower reciprocating weight... The Panhard engines are nice, though. Successful racing engines in their class, in their day. So twinny? How ambitious are you feeling? Weld two panhard twins together to make a flat 4? Mr Millyard makes it look easy I've met Mr Millyard, a chap I used to work with s a diehard biker boy and is good friends with him. Milly used to maintain nuclear reactors for a living so stuff like making 6 pot motorbike engines is child's play - he doesn't even bother drawing plans, just designs it all in his head as he goes along! That Panhard is a thing of beauty.
|
|
Last Edit: Jun 25, 2023 18:07:42 GMT by BritBrick
2005 Volvo C70 2.4T Convertible. 40k miles, FVSH, one prior owner. My toy. 2010 Mini JCW Convertible. Wife's toy. 1991 Yamaha FZR600, one of only 20 Kocinski edition models. MINI Cooper S Electric '3' - My daily scoot. Peugeot 2008 HDi120 - Dog van. Polestar 2 - Wife's daily. Dacia Jogger Extreme hybrid dog van replacement ordered, due Jan '24.
|
|
|
|
|
Also for the Panhard the season is over. I have done some work to narrow down exactly how to fix the rev-counter. As it turns out the cable itself is broken, but as long as it is not under load however it does work. That took me a few attempts to figure out. Had other priorities so have not ordered a new one yet. Also still need to get a spare key sorted, which is turning out not that easy. They have to make it from scratch as there are no blank keys that are a close enough match to start off with. As the material is quite soft also the new key could fail someday. I'm thinking to replace the ignition key with something more modern, as that one is used every time. Locking the car happens less often. I'm tempted to get a upgrade of the lubrication system next year. So higher delivering oil pump, oil filter and an oil cooler. Currently it tends to run hot enough to make the oil very thin and every now and then you can see a flickering of the oil pressure light. Also oil changes quite often when there is no filter. I did get asked for my Panhard to be the example in a purchase advise article in a Dutch magazine. Some pretty nice pictures. Part of the article is online and even in English; though I suspect a automated translation. Panhard purchase article
|
|
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
jamesd1972
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 2,921
Club RR Member Number: 40
|
|
Oct 19, 2023 11:19:49 GMT
|
Sounds like a remote oil filter / temp controlled oil cooler would be good. Any info out there from people competing in these or 2cv's (I know different !) ? Oil cooler would add more oil capacity that sounds like a good thing anyway. Still looking great. James
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
In principle the Panhard engines are fine on lubrication (and giving that it is aircooled also on cooling). It's a weird system however with low flow and to be able to lubricate the roller-bearing crank it includes a lot of splash lubrication, not so much pressure as you would see in a more modern engine. This splash lubrication is one of the reasons why originally every 30.000km the engine had to be opened up as you would get deposits from the oil in strategic places. Thankfully oils are better today. Driving on highways in summer however exposes that the thermal capacity of the (little) amount of oil is simply not enough or is not transferred fast enough through the engine. As a standard rule, your speed in kph is the same as your oil temp. Hot summer days make it a bit worse however. Over the years there have been many modification kits, both from racing and from those that want more useability. But they all share the target to get a bit more oilpump flow (especially at idle), better oil quality (a filter helps in that) and to increase the volume of oil. There are internal oil filter kits which have the benefit you keep the stock look. There are also kits with a external and those have option for an external oil cooler also. I'll have to look into it a bit more what is available and what it means to do the work.
|
|
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
|
|
Oct 20, 2023 21:08:08 GMT
|
I see the Ferrari 512BB was mentioned up there as a tongue in cheek replacement motor, but I saw something online that would be more appropriate (not really tho...) to use in the car. Apparently Panhard themselves made a 6 litre flat 12, that was used in a type of armoured car. 200hp would be pretty entertaining, though I don't know that there'd be any room left to sit in the car if you fitted one.It looks for all the world like they just stacked more cylinders together. Do these look like car cylinders? It'd be funny if there was actual parts interchangeability. Belonged in this... With sound...
|
|
Last Edit: Oct 21, 2023 9:22:45 GMT by horrido
|
|
|
|
|
One of the reasons that there are still quite a few engine parts around for Panhards is indeed that there is commonality with a lot of military stuff; the branch of Panhard that kept existing and via Renault ended up in the Volvo Group (not the Cars, the one with all the heavy vehicles).
At first glance, this looks like one of those engines that shares parts. There are some parts however that were simplified for military use and reliability that however can make things worse.
An example is the piston. For the cars the piston is designed such that the connecting rod is attached slightly off-center which ensures the piston stays gliding on the same side of the cylinder. On the military ones, it is centered (easier to mount as you don't have to pay attention to which way round), which causes it to flip sides at every TDC which does not just cause a weird sound but is also long-term damaging. For military, the ease of mounting was more important. Plenty of rebuilt Panhard engines drive with these military pistons and therefore sound different.
|
|
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
|
|
|
As things arrived way ahead of schedule I can give a preview of a modification to the Panhard. It has something to do with the round cover on the engine sump.. I will add this modification to the oil system. Its a higher output oil pump and a internal oil filter. So why do this? The Panhard engine has a roller bearing crank and that brings the unique challenge (known from some motorcycles also) that a pressure lubrication system is not possible. Instead it uses a splash lubrication which is supported by small metal plates on the crankshaft that launch oil to the right places. However the valve train has a primitive form of hydraulic tappets and in general needs pressure lubrication. The camshaft also is (partly) pressure lubricated. This means the oil pump is a compromise between delivering volume (for the splash lubrication) and pressure (though only 1 to 1,5 bar). Did I also mention its aircooled so that means the oil also has to transfer heat? The metal plates on the crankshaft that launch the oil are a location where some spots have very low oil flow. Any dirt in the oil is therefore depositing there. And the Panhard engines don't have oil filters - as that would strain the oil pump too much. Originally this was solved by a maintenance action every 30-50.000km or so to clean those plates - which is a crankshaft out of engine job that was often skipped. Now enter modern oils... these have dopes in them that help to set deposits in locations with very little oil flow which is normally the oil filter. When used in a Panhard engine this means it deposits on the metal plates which requires much more frequent crankshaft cleaning. I have resolved this by an oil change every 500km since the rebuild. Thats OKish as my yearly mileage is not that much more. Still not preferred. However additionally my engine struggles with warm summer weather as the oil gets very hot and the little oil pressure there is then starts dropping. But other oils would overwhelm the oil pump or would upset the balance of flow versus pressure. This mod gives an oil pump of 1.7x the capacity which also allows a bit higher oil pressures. But even better it allows higher flows which does a lot for heat transfer so oil temperatures stays more under control. And additionally it uses a oil filter so the deposits go to the filter instead of the crankshaft. It's a filter as used on some Smart cars. Best of all. The whole package fits where the original oil pump and sump cover would go. So its invisible and has no exposed parts on the outside. Also it does not stick out under the car which could be a risk. This should make the Panhard much more driveable and no anxious looks anymore to the oil pressure light. Installment will be done in summer. Its not a massive job and engine can stay in the car. Only thing to watch out for is that the shaft for the ignition distributor is driven from the oilpump so don't mess up the timing. Someone in France developed this kit known as Paillou. I got it via the Panhard club.
|
|
Last Edit: Jan 26, 2024 9:59:38 GMT by engineer
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
|
|
|
Besides a new battery also a upgrade to LED brake lights. Much better visibility now. Took it out for a tour of the local Panhard club for the first time. On arrival a crowd gathered but to my surprise the differences to factory original were noticed but not criticized. Also I feared a bit that the rest all have concours level quality cars but actually that isn't much the case. Mine fits in well. One of the practical reasons to participate was that I needed a few parts from the club warehouse. But as the event was just some 24 hours after I returned from a business trip to China I completely forgot to pre-order them. We'll get it someday. On return home we found the rear left tyre nearly flat and very quickly it went completely flat. So no driving until that is sorted. No obvious leaks were found. Suspect now is that the inner tube (yes its that old) has been rubbing on the tyre inner wall. As tyres nowadays are pretty much all designed for tube-less they don't have a smooth finish on the inside anymore and this causes wear. Let's see what the cause really is. Would hate have to either make changes to the wheel so inner tubes are no longer needed or to have to change all tyres to a different and hard to find type.
|
|
V-8: 1988 Corvette - 5.7 TPI V-4: 1973 SAAB 96 - 1.5 4-boxer: 1975 Alfa Romeo AlfaSud - 1.2 2-boxer: 1965 Panhard 24BT - 0.8 4-line: 1982 Suzuki SC100 Whizzkid - 1.0 4-line: 1997 Alfa Romeo 164 Super - 2.0 TS 4-line: 2010 Renault Wind - 1.2 Turbo 4-line: 2021 Citroen campervan - 2.2 HDI 4-line: 2022 Alpine A110 - 1.8 Turbo 2-line: 1973 NSU Prinz 4L - 0.6 --> for sale 2-line: 2021 Honda Rebel 500 EV: 2024 Nio ET5T
|
|
|