I don't think tuning is the dark side
sonus, surely making it faster is seeing the light!
Some lovely mods there on your build. The Type Y cam followers look a nice fit!
On the cam followers front I'm pleased to say that I've been mislead by old sources, and that new cam followers are available from the usual suppliers, DMG etc. They're not cheap, but a lot cheaper than having old ones refurbished would be I'm sure.
If I went down the modern electronics stuff in the future, I'd like to try a Speeduino ECU. It runs on the same softwear as Megasquirt, which I'm very familiar with, and whilst it doesn't have the flexibility that Megasquirt has, it would do everything I need of it.
skylinedave, I saw that block and did consider it for a bit. But without going to see it in person, which I wouldn't consider an 'essential journey' right now, there's no way of telling that it's any better than mine. Pictures of oil and dirt covered bores could easily be as bad as mine. On one of the photos you can see one of the main bearings looking worn right down to the copper, same as mine are, so it could easily be as bad. This is why it's such a gamble buying these parts online. I can't se a full engine for £600? The cheapest full engine I can see is £900 and it looks pretty corroded on the outside, and again without closely inspecting it in person it could be just as bad as mine or worse.
That's an interesting point
wildy . I think from what I've seen already of pulling this engine apart, I suspect the blocked passages in the heads and block were the root cause of my overheating, but it's always possible the gearbox wasn't helping matter.
I've been carrying on with my autopsy over the past couple of days, and its been a pretty mixed bag and finally ended with a bit of a shock. I got the timing chain and bits and bobs off the front of the engine, all of which seemed in fairly good condition. Like the rest of the internal components of this engine, there's very little oil staining and soot which is interesting. Almost all of the second hand parts I see are jet black with oil sludge and staining!
With the timing stuff off I could get the cam out and have a proper look at it. It's not quite as bad as it seemed from the first pictures I don't think, not all of the lobes are in such bad condition and the bearings and journals look alright. Still it would clearly be silly to try and reuse it.
Looking into the valley with the cam removed I could see just how much crud was in there, some if it being big old chunks. Those black bits next ot my glove are solid flakes.
I couldn't say what the chunks are, they could be rust flakes or they could be carbon? Either way, I suspect this is what's gone through the engine causing all the scoring damage I've seen. Given how clean the rest of the engine looks, I wonder if a previous owner used some oil flushing type products without realising there was this large oil bath in the valley? And therefore leaving this big chunks of carbon/debris behind?
Digging in to the bottom end, I was preparing to start marking up the con rods to make sure I know which way round they go, when I spotted that they were all stamped with their location, and handily this also tells me which way round they go and keeps the rod caps the right way round too.
Pulling the pistons out, they looks 'ok' but quite worn to me. All the pistons look very alike with light carbon on the top, all rings looking undamaged, clean and free. I can only compare them to rings out of 2 strokes (as that's my main engine work experience) but I'd almost say they look like they've been replaced recently? You can also see from the size and chunky-ness of that rod, why they can take the power they can! All of the pistons and all of the bores measure up as close enough to standard that I believe they're original, which at leats means there's room to bore the block out to oversize still.
6 of the big end bearings had scoring like this one, which is clearly debris in the oil and I would suggest is very recent as the damage is confined to the area directly above the oil hole in the crank journal.
All of the big end bearings are stamped VP which, from what I've read, suggests they are original. Likewise the front and rear main bearings are stamped VP but the centre 3 main bearing, which are the heavily worn ones, are stamped VP STD. So while they are the OE brand, it makes me think they are replacements?
Moving on to the crank, the journals all look 'ok' to me. The oil was very brown and dirty under some of the road bearings, actual dirt/rust rather than old oil.
This surprised me as when I bought the car the oil was very clean looking, and I had since had the sump off and through cleaned it out before refitting and filling with new oil. Maybe the engine had corroded inside the oil galleries, and that's what's spitting debris into my bearings and killing them?
I haven't got as far as checking the sludge traps in the crank, but it's on my to do list. I imagine they're full of debris also.
Anyway wiping the oil away there's some light scoring on the crank, most of it I couldn't feel but across the centre where the oiling hole of the worst couple of journals I could just about feel something with my finger nail. I believe it would polish out? Here is a picture of the worst journal.
I did attempt to measure the journals but I'm not sure my digital 'micrometer' is upto the job. I measured them all as 0.003" - 0.004" under, which according to my manual is just past the wear limit. But I got the same 0.003" undersized measurement when I measured the sections of the journal that the bearings didn't run over, which suggests there's no measurable wear? It could well me that my cheap digital micrometer isn't accurate enough really. Or if could be that in the past someone's polished the crank down to this size? On the positive side, regardless of the exact numbers, I could tell that they were all even and showed no signs of ovality. So would hopefully be no problem to have it ground 0.010" under if needs be.
Moving on to the oil pump, removing the cover I didn't see lots of circular scoring on the top lid or top of the pump gears, which gave me a bit of hope. But I think the straight lines scratches suggest that someone has tried to give this pump some extra life by sanding down the body and gears to tighten up the clearances. The pump gear to top cap clearance was still past the wear limit anyway.
Then removing the gears showed that the pump body was heavily scored inside along the walls, and also had some rust. So I believe this pump is only fit for the bin (or being given in part exchange for a refurbished one I guess!)
The oil pressure relieve valve was also rusted and scored.
So by this point I'm thinking "this all looks curse word', but it's still just a case of wear and not catastrophic failure...
And then I spent a long time with various wire brush pipe cleaners and a hose pipe trying to clear out all of the crud from the cooling jacket around the cylinders, which was a lovely fun job. I didn't get any pictures but, as you can imagine, there was serious amounts of crud wedged in there. When I'd got the worst of the crud out, it would need another session to get the last of it out, I gave the whole block a bit of a once over and clean down. Immediately a spotted a rather big problem.
No idea how I didn't see that spectacularly big crack before. I think it must have been covered over with corrosion and remains of the head gasket. I'd say looking at it's position, that it's frost damage. The freeze plug next to it was pushed almost out of the block and looks to have been leaking a little.
So thats really bad news. I think this might be the straw that breaks the camels back. The extra cost of trying to have that fixed, if it's even fixable, might just tip the tables on the economic viability of continuing with this engine. I'm starting to think that looking out for another engine/short block that 'only' needs a light refresh (bearings ,rings hone, etc) rather than this level of deep rebuild, might make more financial sense.
As mentioned near the top of this post, in order to judge that I'll clearly need to go view the engines in person, rather than relying on some eBay photos, so I guess that's gotta wait till the lockdown is lifted. Even then it will be a bit of a gamble.
Still I've got plenty of time to mull over my options I guess! For now I'll just shut the shed door and mope!
Anyone wanna swap a stupid broken old Daimler for a car that actually works?