cjhillman
Posted a lot
1979 Capri (Rolling Project) 1985 Escort mk3 (Daily)
Posts: 1,588
|
|
|
It's that time again where I'm thinking, I should really consider a "modern" daily. Theres no immediate need but you know how it is, you get the idea and start looking on ebay at what floats your boat. Being me I always think If I'm selling something retro/cool for a modern, I'd like something that looks good too! I started looking at Minis then stumbled across the Mondeo mk3, specifically the ST TDCI! As a Ford fanatic I can't believe I didn't know about this ST! The mk3 seems like its getting a bit Retro now and I've been told by my misses she thinks its already too old. I can't ignor theres not as many on the road while out and about and the mk4 is more popular (not really a fan tbh). Like any Car I bet if I bought a later run out model you could get away with it as a legitimate daily? Tell me about them though! The ST TDCI seems perfect if you want something that looks cool but returns good MPG as daily? Also what are the major problems with these cars? What do you look for when buying them? Can they be fixed quickly by any garage? Cheap to fix? I'm guessing this TDCI engine is in a few other Fords? I noticed the prices on Auto trader ranger from £1500 - over £4k Looks like in a couple of years they will be going up in value. I'm particularly attracted to the Blue and Black Hatchback models. I can imagine eating up the miles in a ASBO Blue ST but getting decent TDCI MPG?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
They suffer from the typical modern diesel issues like EGR, DPF, DMF and injectors. Injectors are £90 each and need coding but you can do it at home with free software (ForScan), EGR & DPF get mapped out and never give any issues afterwards.
|
|
|
|
cjhillman
Posted a lot
1979 Capri (Rolling Project) 1985 Escort mk3 (Daily)
Posts: 1,588
|
|
|
Good to know! I though I read they were free from DPFs as they’re too old?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Some did post 2007, earlier ones had a cat that can be removed with a delete pipe from ebay
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TDCI Mondeos were a bad buy ten years ago, as it was entirely possible to spend out on a new flywheel(including the clutch and starter motor that was the fault the car went in with), injectors and fuel pump one after the other. Each of those was a four figure expense, which lead to a rash of £500 cars. I'm amazed there are any left. If you must have a Mondeo, which is a pretty good car, buy a petrol.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Can't comment on the ST TDCi but have run a couple of 2.5 Ghia X estates and they are very practical/usable cars... albeit the V6 was horrendously uneconomical, and not as quick as I hoped.. Later models very well equipped.
Problems, rust(but that turned out to be a repair gone bad).
Rear calipers could bind(handbrake mech usually) or leak from said mech.
Models tend to break springs quite frequently in my experience(replace 7 across the 2 cars for breakage).
Other weird fault was a sheared rear subframe bolt - knocking noise that took ages to trace.
|
|
2014 - Audi A6 Avant 3.0Tdi Quattro 1958 - Chevrolet Apache Panel Truck 1959 - Plymouth Custom Suburban 1952 - Chevrolet 2dr Hardtop 1985 - Ford Econoline E350 Quadravan 2009 - Ovlov V70 2.5T 1970 - Cortina Mk2 Estate 2007 - Fiat Ducato LWB 120Multijet 2014 - Honda Civic 2.2 CTDi ES
|
|
|
|
|
They were a bad buy when the injectors were £1500 a set, they're so cheap now it doesn't matter if they need sorting. There's more diesels left than petrols, many with >200K miles and still running fine.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Just bought an 09 2.2 MK4 TX. I like it. Big bills come with any car. Its how it is.
High insurance put me off the ST. Eats miles with ease. Comfortable.
|
|
|
|
cjhillman
Posted a lot
1979 Capri (Rolling Project) 1985 Escort mk3 (Daily)
Posts: 1,588
|
|
|
Good to know the reality of costs with these. Is the flywheel/clutch not the same as most DMF diesels? My dad just had to have his clutch done in a 2011 A3 TDi and that was about £800.
Didn’t really think about the insurance… I should try a quote on one of these. Weirdly I noticed on Autotrader the tax across all the mk3 Mondeos is £200+ The springs breaking seems pretty strange!?
I know anything will be more expensive than I have now. Both my cars are 37 and 44 years old. My Capri only cost £130 to insure for the year.
Are they a nice drive though? And I’m guessing they’re fairly quick. Really like driving my Dads A3 TDI.
|
|
Last Edit: Mar 8, 2023 12:06:48 GMT by cjhillman
|
|
brachunky
Scotland
Posts: 1,316
Club RR Member Number: 72
|
|
|
I think these are really underestimated cars having had 2 some time back. They are an enjoyable ride with enough creature comforts to make a comfortable cabin. As mentioned dual mass flywheels can be pricy if needed and don't be tempted by the original factory integrated satnav system. When they go wrong you loose so much functionality as things like ac controls are operated by the touch screen. They would often freeze making you have to stop & restart the car to use them again! Other than that, I think they are great future retro cars especially the saloon and come to think of it, the estate on banded steels may look cool too.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
They're very comfortable, especially with heated and air conditioned leathers. The ST estates are the one to go for imho.
|
|
|
|
rodharris83
Club Retro Rides Member
Day Dreamer...
Posts: 760
Club RR Member Number: 4
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
mrbig
Part of things
Semi-professional Procrastinator
Posts: 462
|
|
|
Fabulous cars, well mine was (albeit an ST220, so the petrol equivalent).
I believe the injectors can be a bit fragile on these, as already mentioned, and a clutch/dual mass flywheel replacement will sting a bit.
Watch for rust, bottoms of the doors was a favourite and rear subframe bushes too! Mine had these flagged as an advisory and then a week later a tyre exploded at 70 mph because the inner tyre wall had been rubbing on a bracket on the shock absorber, such was the level of movement in the rear subframe!
|
|
1969 German Look Beetle - in progress
|
|
cjhillman
Posted a lot
1979 Capri (Rolling Project) 1985 Escort mk3 (Daily)
Posts: 1,588
|
|
|
I was just reading astranaut 's problems with the fuel filter/ injectors. Sounds like It can still be a costly problem that? Does that go for normal 2.0 TDCI's as well? Insurance wise for a 35 year old with 9 years no claims. 07 ST TDCI £448 with the AA 04 2.0 TDCi Ghia X with the AA £381 Not bad £67 more for a "sports" model for a Musician with business insurance.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Loved my old ST, never missed a beat & one of the most reliable cars I ever owned. Purchased it blind off Ford Direct and was not disappointed. Only issue was loosing the jacking point covers!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Righty ho, it goes for MOT tomoro, want to buy it? Had mine 5 years now, in that time it's had 3 crank pulleys (gates or corteco, not ebay wibblepoo) 2 aux belt tensioners (again not cheap wibblepoo), 1 starter motor (this wasn't changed when the clutch and fly was done just before I got it, the material just destroys the starter so I'll let it off that one). Wheel bearings all around, I suspect it needs another n/so front, it seems to eat them. Brake pipes all round, they're at that age now where they're grotty Shocks all around (again just old and lowered) 2 EGR valves, I gave up when the last one went and blanked it, if you buy 06 onward this will have an electric EGR and bring on an EML, early cars are vacuum and don't. Injector seals are weeping, I need to look into this as there is diesel pooling on the rocker cover It's just had its first bout of welding, I thouggt they were immune, and to look at mine has no rust anywhere - just had to replace 3 foot of the n/s sill, unless you can jack it up and get your hand beneath the skirt you won't see this, and the skirts are bonded on from factory with weapons grade sealant. Power steering pipe - gone through 2 of these, they have a silly clip arrangement and when it blows you need a new nut from Ford. If you don't clip it in exactly right first time it's buggered, I got around this by fitting a second hand pipe and pump, which also got rid of another known issue of slightly sticky steering when cold. Now has an intermittent issue with either the actuator or the variable vanes in the turbo I need to look at That odd issue I had - it coughed and died, gave me all the fault codes for fuel pump, symptoms of fuel pump, my mechanic said for the sake of 6 quid throw a fuel filter on, prime it - and it worked, for some unknown reason it had just emptied its own fuel filter and wouldnt run, been fine for 6k now since. I do like mine, I'm hoping it passes tomoro, but they do have their issues, engine is agricultural and doesntnreally take well to mods, mine with the right induction kit, big front mount intercooler, decat with 3" stainless to the back and a remap is probably only 190 at best, after that your into hybrid turbos and injectors but even then 220 is probably your limit. And it won't be reliable. On a run mine will do 55mpg, that's a 210k engine, around 42 round the houses. But it's a mondeo so good chassis, reasonable pull, get 5 adults in and a decent boot. Those jacking point covers though, if you buy one and you have them all, glue them there, same with the rear bumper reflectors, they're expensive even second hand. Good news is though that because they entered cheap car territory when I bought mine (700 with a new clutch and fly in 2018) many have been driven to death and they're now all dying, so plenty of breakers about. Garage wise, aux belt tensioner is a pain to do, lack of room, and a clutch and fly will be at least 700. Fuel pump is the biggest, if that goes swarf from it ruins the injectors, it gets costly then. Otherwise its just a Mondeo, the TDCi literally had recaros as an extra, and wider front wings to accommodate the bumper and sideskirts, there's nothing else special apart from colours. Have a pic of mine when it was clean, it's clean now for the first time in months but it's also snowing
|
|
Last Edit: Mar 8, 2023 17:54:18 GMT by astranaut
|
|
ChasR
RR Helper
motivation
Posts: 10,194
Club RR Member Number: 170
|
|
|
I've had several Mk3 Mondeos, as many know. The Crusher ST220 link above was mine, and was a V6.
They have old car problems like the:
-Subframe bushes on non estate cars -handbrake calipers -Steering racks if the wrong fluid is put in -DMFs, if the engine has been laboured alot, abused, had harsh gear changes from a thrasher, or had a badly running engine.
But that can happen to most old cars. Christ, my 325d and my dad's Saab 9-3 are now on rebuilt brake calipers! It's just the way old cars go!
The TDCI engines, however, have 2 pros
-They are very torquey -They do crazy MPG, even by today's standards.
That said, what is given with one hand is taken with another.
-Fuel pumps are fragile. Unless the car has a history of the odd good tank of V-Power diesel put in, only genuine fuel filters used, and having the tank full (these don't run a lift pump), the pumps can live alot longer than you think. Unfortunately, many have been abused.
The fuel pump tends to die, which then will take out the entire injection system.
Cars like the above, or genuine Ford service history cars exist but they are getting pricier to buy.
The fuel filter is worth a note as bar a Premium Bosch filter (there are two grades of filter from them), a Delphi or a genuine Ford, all other filters don't filter as well, which again, destroys the fuel pump over time.
For the above reasons, I can't recommend one, unless you are sure beyond doubt that you have a car like the above. I only know of two. When I used to drive for a living, almost all TDCis that weren't maintained like the above were scrapped before 7 years old and 160,000 miles. They really don't do neglect well.
The petrols are a much better bet. They are ULEZ exempt and bar oil consumption on some engines (this is luck of the draw), they can do huge mileages. My dad and I have taken 3 of these 4 pots between 200-387k with minimal work on the engine. The V6s don't like poor cooling systems, but with this sorted, they again can do big miles.
The 2.0s are the sweet spot, but the 1.8s are better on fuel, albeit workmanlike in pace.
The Mk4s are a better bet with a sturdier engine, and a more cruiser car feel, but at the cost of worse fuel economy, with them using the DW10 engine from Peugeot. They also don't drive as 'sporty/thrilling' as a Mk3, due to them being a larger car, with more of an emphasis on comfort. That said, I did adore my Mk4 2.5 Turbo 5 pot.
|
|
Last Edit: Mar 9, 2023 6:53:48 GMT by ChasR
|
|
Ratchet
Part of things
The user formerly known as Thomas
Posts: 676
|
|
|
My boyfriend has had a 56 plate 2.0tdci estate since it was 3 or 4 years old, not an ST though but a weird spec as it has body coloured door handles and mirrors, wind up rear windows.. and voice activation for the radio and aircon.
Currently just passed 250k miles on it, was his daily until last year only got retired from that after it got crashed into twice(!) and he got an electric MG5 for daily duty, kept this for moving stuff as has a huge loadspace etc
only real issues with it in that time were: Crank pully.. it used to break them and subsequently the tensioner for fun, cheap ones lasted 6 months, good quality brand ones were better but 3x the price, what finally cured it though was fitting a freewheel to the alternator, so worth doing if its not done aleady.
The fuel system self destructed a few years back (it had previously got rebuilt injectors after contaminated fuel killed them.. those were 'rebuilt' by somoene but were never right) i pulled out the entire fuel system, and replaced/cleaned it all, as as well as the metal in the system, engine oil had been leaking into the transfer pump and the inside of the fuel tank was black
Recently fitted a new map sensor after the original died while it was parked up.. and now its getting high 50s mpg again, has been giving low 50s for years and put it down to worn engine but apparently not, guess it was faulty for years, so something to look out for, its in a pretty stupid place on the lower turbo pipework and held in with two tiny hex head bolts.
EGRs clog up, as has been mentioned, the valves themselves also fail, but again avoid the cheap unbranded ones.
rear suspension on the estate is an interesting multi link design and completly different to the saloons, more bushes and links to check for wear though
There are a few trim parts that are already getting a bit hard to find, example is the gromit where the brake pushrod enters the engine bay, it disintigrates, and you get a bunch of engine abd road noise, can only get them from ford and its made of foam, the first replacement i got had melted in the packaging in the 6 months between buying it and going to fit it so i suspect they are all old stock now.... however a ford cougar one fits, and its made of proper rubber
|
|
Competition is the law of the jungle, but cooperation is the law of civilization.
1971 vw beetle 1200 1978 international loadstar 1700 4x4 1987 landrover 110 1994 Yamaha FZR600r 2010 honda CBF100GT
|
|
cjhillman
Posted a lot
1979 Capri (Rolling Project) 1985 Escort mk3 (Daily)
Posts: 1,588
|
|
|
Righty ho, it goes for MOT tomoro, want to buy it? Had mine 5 years now, in that time it's had 3 crank pulleys (gates or corteco, not ebay wibblepoo) 2 aux belt tensioners (again not cheap wibblepoo), 1 starter motor (this wasn't changed when the clutch and fly was done just before I got it, the material just destroys the starter so I'll let it off that one). Wheel bearings all around, I suspect it needs another n/so front, it seems to eat them. Brake pipes all round, they're at that age now where they're grotty Shocks all around (again just old and lowered) 2 EGR valves, I gave up when the last one went and blanked it, if you buy 06 onward this will have an electric EGR and bring on an EML, early cars are vacuum and don't. Injector seals are weeping, I need to look into this as there is diesel pooling on the rocker cover It's just had its first bout of welding, I thouggt they were immune, and to look at mine has no rust anywhere - just had to replace 3 foot of the n/s sill, unless you can jack it up and get your hand beneath the skirt you won't see this, and the skirts are bonded on from factory with weapons grade sealant. Power steering pipe - gone through 2 of these, they have a silly clip arrangement and when it blows you need a new nut from Ford. If you don't clip it in exactly right first time it's buggered, I got around this by fitting a second hand pipe and pump, which also got rid of another known issue of slightly sticky steering when cold. Now has an intermittent issue with either the actuator or the variable vanes in the turbo I need to look at That odd issue I had - it coughed and died, gave me all the fault codes for fuel pump, symptoms of fuel pump, my mechanic said for the sake of 6 quid throw a fuel filter on, prime it - and it worked, for some unknown reason it had just emptied its own fuel filter and wouldnt run, been fine for 6k now since. I do like mine, I'm hoping it passes tomoro, but they do have their issues, engine is agricultural and doesntnreally take well to mods, mine with the right induction kit, big front mount intercooler, decat with 3" stainless to the back and a remap is probably only 190 at best, after that your into hybrid turbos and injectors but even then 220 is probably your limit. And it won't be reliable. On a run mine will do 55mpg, that's a 210k engine, around 42 round the houses. But it's a mondeo so good chassis, reasonable pull, get 5 adults in and a decent boot. Those jacking point covers though, if you buy one and you have them all, glue them there, same with the rear bumper reflectors, they're expensive even second hand. Good news is though that because they entered cheap car territory when I bought mine (700 with a new clutch and fly in 2018) many have been driven to death and they're now all dying, so plenty of breakers about. Garage wise, aux belt tensioner is a pain to do, lack of room, and a clutch and fly will be at least 700. Fuel pump is the biggest, if that goes swarf from it ruins the injectors, it gets costly then. Otherwise its just a Mondeo, the TDCi literally had recaros as an extra, and wider front wings to accommodate the bumper and sideskirts, there's nothing else special apart from colours. Have a pic of mine when it was clean, it's clean now for the first time in months but it's also snowing Good luck with the MOT mate! How did it go? I did read through your build thread the other day. Sounds like you've had your fair share of problems but like you said I guess they've all had a bit of a life now and thats some pretty good mileage! If I bought one I'd be keeping it mechanically standard for reliability. I'm starting to think they might not be as reliable as I hoped haha. Does the crank pulley just turn the Aux belt or is it on the timing belt too? or is this engine a chain? Sounds like a bit of a pain. Are the fuel filters expensive too? ChasR I was just reading through your Mondeo thread. I remember you mentioning it at RR Gathering too. Might be on to avoid for me. If I buy something like this I would be to have a break from constant car maintenance. Sounds like I'd be driving down the M6 heading to a gig worrying about the fuel system, suspension springs or crank pulley haha. Shame they didnt do any Yellows or Orange Mondeo mk3's from the factory.
|
|
|
|
philsford
Part of things
Posts: 733
Club RR Member Number: 100
|
|
|
I have had both petrol and diesel st versions and 2 x 2.0 tdci and tddi. As above injectors, flywheel and fuel pumps along with rust. If you buy one just treat the half tank mark as empty, I always did this and never ran into pump trouble. It's been a while but something changed on the engine when the side skirts were updated on St tdci models (dpf fitted maybe) I bought a 55 plate at the time to avoid that. I never gelled with the st tdci and I got rid, I would have another 2.0 tdci but I would be willing to throw it away if something expensive came up. Do you do many miles? A 1.6 petrol focus is more robust item in my experience you have to do a lot of miles to make a diesel make sense or a need for a bigger car. With fuel prices the way they are a petrol car doing approximately 40mpg is as cheap to run as a diesel doing 47mpg without considering the repair bills.
|
|
|
|
|