gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
|
Thanks for all the updates...the diff backlash is certainly a problem. I have an MX 2.5 S-VT and it had a noisy 6 speed gearbox but it got quieter as you went up through the box...Swapped it for a much better one now though. You're very welcome! I'll compare it to the other MX5 and I already have a spare gearbox lined up to try... Putting that off though! Shame to be having the drivel one issues so soon after swapping the engine in, hope you get to the bottom of it soon. Regarding the amount of pinion backlash, I've noticed a similar situation on some other diffs I've owned, notably the diff from Spitfire recently. I also noticed what seemed like a lot of backlash at the pinion, but them pulling the diff apart and measuring the backlash at the CROWN wheel also found it perfectly in specification. I guess the nature of the small pinion Vs large CROWN wheel means the backlash if magnified. The play into the gearbox on the other hand sounded eerily familliar - although there was far less movement. I'm thinking that the noise I'm hearing is somehow caused by the propshaft 'vibrating' at low loads, and the noise itself is actually from the gearbox. One thing that crosses my mind here is the old PPF alignment on Mk1 Mx5? I know from experience just how much noise the standard Mx5 gearbox can make when it's not quite aligned right on the PPF. Strangely enough with the diff open I can't find the same play on the pinion - the output splines spin immediately - even when I'm trying to put some force on them by hand. That made me think that perhaps the play was in the output shaft splines, but they don't show any signs of wear. I was under the impression the PPF alignment created vibration and noises at speed... I will do some more reading Due to my engine sitting slightly further forward in the engine bay that ideal I didn't have much choice in PPF alignment - getting it to fit was an achievement! Which means you might have a good point. What a fantastic build thread. I don’t know if I’ve commented in here before but I’ve certainly followed with interest. How do you find the handling of the car now your conversion is installed? I ask because I visited a company down my way called TDI south located next door to AMD. When I was in there they had a few MX5s with various engine conversions, from memory a F20C, SR20 and I can’t remember the others. The owner said he struggled to get the centre of balance correct to retain the great handling and driving experience he had with a standard car. This was nearly 10 years ago now, so I suppose far more research and development has gone into the conversion you have installed but it would be interesting to hear. Sorry if this has already been covered. Do you still have your 944? How do you feel the MX-5 compares? I was recently watching a “Smoking Tyre” episode on YouTube with a modified 944 turbo, the presenter described it as “it feels like a faster Mx-5” which I disagreed with. Would you say the two are comparable? Obviously I understand your 944 is not a turbo model and your MX-5 statistics are far greater than that of the 944. It would be interesting to hear your opinion. I’ve owned both and felt the Mx5 was far more nimble. Thanks, I think you did a few pages back... maybe? I've yet to get it geo'd so can't really comment on handling and weight balance yet. I'll get it on some cornerweight scales at some point to compare to a standard MX5 but it should be very similar. It's harder to work out what it's done to the roll centre - With a lighter subframe and lighter ally block and two heads I suspect it may have raised it a little. MX5 vs 944... Never ending argument and everyone seems to have their own opinion. To me they may look like they should be similar and share some ideas, but they are completely different cars - from behind the steering wheel and from an engineering, tuning and technology standpoint. My take on it is that the 944 is a GT car through and though. Nimble? Not in the slightest. B roads? Too big and rolly. Sustained speeds of 70+ while looking badass? Absolutely. It comes into it's own over ~60, very stable, confident and solid. To me that kinda translates into a bit boring for most of the driving I do. Also as mine isn't a turbo it might be great at speed but takes ages to get there - a stock 1.8 mx5 leaves it in the dust. Engineering wise they come from two very different mindsets. The mx5 is decidedly flimsy in comparison - take the front subframe, thin pressed steel that bends if you try to use it as a jacking point. 944 - Massive cast aluminium crossmember. Powetrain wise they're pretty similar in concept. Even though the 944 uses the transaxle and torque tube with the gearbox at the back, the MX5 has a traditional front gearbox and prop shaft but has the power plant frame (PPF) that carries the torsional loading between the gearbox and the diff - very similar in concept to the torque tube. Suspension wise they're worlds apart however with the 944's Golf mk1 McPhearson struts at the front and SuperBeetle torsion bar at the rear, compared to the MX5 narrow spaced double wishbone and coilovers at each corner. I think the biggest difference though was the initial design requirements for the two cars. The 944 was engineered and tuned with the autobahn in mind, the MX5 was benchmarked against MGB's and lotus's. The MX5 is light and nimble to drive in comparison, loves being chucked down a B road at lower speeds, far more alive in the corners and just feels like it takes itself less seriously (I might be reading too much into the car there!). It flexes, it rattles, it squeaks. Point it at a dual carriage way and it doesn't like it much. Where the 944 hunkers down and is deceivingly fast, the MX5 is jittery and pointy, the engine is revvy and loud and you know every mph increase! (Feels better with the V6, need to drive it more though). If I were doing a road trip to the Alps I'd drive down there in the 944 and then take the MX5 for the alpine passes. I love the 944 for its looks and the noise it makes, but I'm generally left a bit disappointed when I drive it - which I haven't in ages because the body shop is being beyond slow with my new rear arch, I'm still chasing down coolant leaks, and now the rocker cover has started leaking a little oil onto the exhaust manifold. lurvely. The MX5 (v6 or otherwise) leaves me with a smile on my face, so long as it's not a motorway journey! I have the same issues as you with an MX5 4:1 torsen, ive adjusted mine back into limits, the remaining play is inside the torsen worm gears, and isn't really serviceable. Might be better to find a new core, mine isnt as bad as yours even after some 90,000 miles and serious abuse. The cabin diff noise, will be caused by the poly diff bushes, i run them, but mines a track car so who cares. Rubbers are quieter, and you can limit play with super pro limiter donut inserts. 0-60, should be in the 5's. I run 5.1 to 60 with 240hp/250ftlb, so you should be equally as quick! Great to see the rocketeer kit go together! I still really want a V6 mx5!! That is my worry - that the wear is in the diff core. I can't feel it on the bench, but if I put the spare open diff in and it solves the problem then I'll pull the torsen apart and take a good look at it's innards! The earlier MX5 T1 torsens used a traditional torsen worm gear layout, the T2's (mine) use something different and I haven't worked it out yet. I didn't really notice extra diff noise from the polybushes, but again, the replacement has the original rubber bushes so I'll have something to compare to. My 0-60 run was very impromptu and poorly driven - will definitely be able to reduce it by a second or so. Is yours a turbo setup? The V6 does give an excellent soundtrack
|
|
Last Edit: May 6, 2020 14:44:05 GMT by gryphon
|
|
|
|
|
|
Yeah boring and turbocharged,G19 TD05 and 12lbs of boost. (had nitrous, had eaton m90 all on the same motor, never opened it, 2000 track miles nearly).
Would love to strip the torsen down and fix mine and see how it all works, mines also MK2/type2 and 6 speed.
PPF alignment is pretty critical, and easy to get wrong (make sure you knock the dowels in the diff back down into the lower bracket). Mine also needed re-torqueing a couple times, as if it had moved etc.
Turbo mx5's, are like a rough and unfriendly tractor... then they come on boost and sound decent, but not V6 decent!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Just found this thread!
An excellent resource for my own project doing the same but to a Chrysler Sunbeam.
Glad you have found some of the pitfalls first...... :-)
|
|
|
|
gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
|
Well, good news and bad news... the new cheap open differential seems to have solved it. Seals arrived this morning, popped the diff in, barely any free play between the prop shaft and the driveshafts, and a 200m drive up and down the road proved the lash in the drivetrain greatly reduced from what it used to be. So that's the good news.
The bad news is as scimitarse6b called it - the only place for the play to be coming from it my Torsen centre. It would have to be the expensive bit! Good excuse to find a 3.6:1 for it though. Yeah boring and turbocharged,G19 TD05 and 12lbs of boost. (had nitrous, had eaton m90 all on the same motor, never opened it, 2000 track miles nearly). Would love to strip the torsen down and fix mine and see how it all works, mines also MK2/type2 and 6 speed. PPF alignment is pretty critical, and easy to get wrong (make sure you knock the dowels in the diff back down into the lower bracket). Mine also needed re-torqueing a couple times, as if it had moved etc. Turbo mx5's, are like a rough and unfriendly tractor... then they come on boost and sound decent, but not V6 decent! Doesn't sound that boring to me, sounds like you've had fun with it! I'll keep an eye on the bolts - I pulled the dowels into place with the bolts and they looked well seated, but i guess if they find a little more depth the bolts would loose torque pretty quickly.
If I pull apart the T2 (can't see a reason not to at the moment) I'll get lots of pictures
Just found this thread! An excellent resource for my own project doing the same but to a Chrysler Sunbeam. Glad you have found some of the pitfalls first...... :-)
Had a quick peruse of your thread, great project! Good luck with it - and glad I could help
|
|
|
|
|
|
May 12, 2020 11:50:35 GMT
|
Not to hijack or anything...
Boring is a relative term, it was supercharged with a eaton m90 from an aston martin DB7, the sound, the throttle response was unreal. 6.3psi and 229bhp.
But turbo is 0.1s quicker to 60 and just works reliably so meh.
Maybe have a look at RX7 T2 diffs, ive heard there the same, but a plate style diff. RX7's tend to do less miles due to the thirst so may be worth a look.
Stay safe everyone!
|
|
|
|
gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
|
That does look good. We still haven't really played with the Mini M45 supercharger sitting in the garage. Had plans to fit it to the Dakar over lockdown but it didn't happen! RX7 diffs... I've looked and there are a few around, prices vary wildly though. The centre is compatible so I'll keep an eye out. I think it's the FC RX7 that has a compatible but much stronger diff housing that are a popular upgrade for v8 MX5s - the arms on the MX5 diffs are fused to snap under too much torque, although I don't think I'm quite at that level. I'm set on a lower final drive ratio and the most availalbe option seems to be the 3.6. A 3.6 torsen is pricey unicorn droppings, but a 3.6 fuji clutch LSD (well known for clutches failing) would be a month or so's wait and £150, then I'd need a good centre from a torsen and I could combine them into a good differential. Problem is that a good Torsen diff will likely be in the £400 region... I could get a brand new blackline torsen centre for less than £100 more which would likely be £100 well spent for peice of mind. And finally there is a best of all worlds/empty your wallet option that I found courtesy of BOFI racing...Which is a 3.3:1 ratio CROWN and pinion (have only found new for too much money) and a 6-speed gearbox which keeps gears 1-5 in line with what they currently are in my 5 speed with 4.1 diff, then a nice overdrive 6th gear with 70mph cruising under 3k rpm. I really like this solution if I can get the cost down, as I now think the remaining driveline noises have to be from the gearbox and 6 gears appeal... In other news the car passed the first commute milestone: Three 'Jags' in a socially distanced row.... I do rather like the old xf sportbrakes (left) but the new ones don't do it for me. Also I either need to paint the bottom of my wings black, or the sills red... I think I prefer the sills red. V6 sounds goood in the multistory though! Car behaved itself pretty well. Surprisingly I noticed the lack of an LSD, so the old torsen must still have been doing it's job. If I pull away slightly eagerly with the open I get a fair bit of tyre squeal. There is a bad heatshield rattle that appears at sustained speeds of ~70, and my wing mirrors are a bit floppy and slowly get pushed down at speed. I took a look at tighetning the wingmirrors. The adjustment bolts are well known for rusting and snapping - turns out mine have done that, and been 'fixed' by the PO. This fix consisted of a slot head machine screw (slot head... WHY?!), that goes into a nyloc inside the glued together wing mirror housing. This nyloc isn't captive though, so there's no adjusting it without cracking everything open. gah. So cracked it open separated it all, and I'll have to do a better job of fixing it! Captive bolt in the mirror and a nyloc underneath seems a better solution to me. The mirror is a bit rough though, so while I'm there, paint is required... Hopefully we get some decent painting weather soon!
|
|
Last Edit: May 13, 2020 9:58:19 GMT by gryphon
|
|
MiataMark
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 2,971
Club RR Member Number: 29
|
|
|
At least it didn't just snap off like mine did when I went to adjust it after a winter of not being used. I do have some spare mirror innards, I'll see what I've got.
|
|
1990 Mazda MX-52012 BMW 118i (170bhp) - white appliance 2011 Land Rover Freelander 2 TD4 2003 Land Rover Discovery II TD52007 Alfa Romeo 159 Sportwagon JTDm
|
|
gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
May 13, 2020 10:04:32 GMT
|
At least it didn't just snap off like mine did when I went to adjust it after a winter of not being used. I do have some spare mirror innards, I'll see what I've got. The daker passenger side mirror did that a few months ago! It's still running around with one mirror... MX5's and rusty bolts, who'd have thought! I think I've got everthing I need to fix them for now, the captive metal plate is still in the mirrors, I just need to stick a bolt to it
|
|
|
|
MiataMark
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 2,971
Club RR Member Number: 29
|
|
May 13, 2020 11:07:06 GMT
|
I was thinking of getting some Raydot mirrors from Moss but they won't fit my early doors.
|
|
1990 Mazda MX-52012 BMW 118i (170bhp) - white appliance 2011 Land Rover Freelander 2 TD4 2003 Land Rover Discovery II TD52007 Alfa Romeo 159 Sportwagon JTDm
|
|
gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
May 13, 2020 11:39:47 GMT
|
Are they much good as a functional mirror? They look small!
Mirrors are function over form for me. I like to be able to see where I've been.
|
|
|
|
|
gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
May 22, 2020 14:25:05 GMT
|
I spent a pretty chilled weekend trying to paint the mirrors nicely... I'm very much still learning as I go with painting, so the mirrors seemed a good little practice job. (and some of you may have seen my 'help!!' posts in the body and paint thread!) I have a load of boring pictures of semi painted mirrors for you... So mirrors off and the rough areas sanded down / all keyed for primer (pic half way through the job, you can see how poor the old mirror was): A coat of primer all round, left sanded down with 800 grit, right was the finish out of the can: Now Jowel had a 3 for 2 offer on the UPOL cans... but that didn't include a proper basecoat. They recommended the satin black as a basecoat to then clearcoat. The satin black finish came out as: Which looked pretty good to me... Clearcoat over it didn't come out so nicely though! At this point I asked for some help on the body and paint thread... the advice was that the paint looked too thick and dry, and it needed to be lighter and wetter. I'd always equated a thick coat to a wet coat before so spent a little time puzzling, and realised that I'd been building the 'wet' coat with lots of fast passes as I felt that gave me more of a feeling for when the paint would start running. In reality it was building up a rather pitted coating. I ended up sanding back the satin layer on the mirrors and starting again with much slower passes, giving my 'wet' layer in a single pass, and the result was far smoother paint! The other comment I got was 'why are you using satin?'... Despite Jawel recommending it, I don't think I'd do it again - the clear finish over it isn't great. This was the clear on the second attempt: Improved but not great. I was probably a little too impatient and about 24 hours later hit it with a little 2000 grit sandpaper and some G3 polish and was rather pleased with the results: Unfortunately that's gone a fair bit duller again, so I'll try the polish again after it's had a week or two to fully harden. Then gluing the mirror back together... Previously the glass had fallen back into the mirror housing a little bit. From the factory there is a bit of foam tape behind the mirror glass holding it forwards, but it's now a bit too thin to do the job properly. I replaced that with thicker tape that should do nicely: A friend with a welder tacked the bolts into the metal plates in the mirror to replace the nyloc that was spinning, then I glued it all together. I didn't want to use an epoxy in case I wanted to get inside together so at the moment I've tried with 'Shoe Goo', which is a rubberised plastic glue that works very well on shoes and trainers, and I happened to have a tube of it handy. It seems to have worked. The little red bits were painted with a proper basecoat and had a far nicer out the can finish that I completely failed to get a photo of!And all done, a car with black mirrors: Now I need to paint the windscreen surround black too... Not sure I trust myself to do that nicely yet though. Might practice by turning the sills red and have a go at tidying up the rear arches with a little filler. They need re-doing anyway so seem a good area to practice on. Enough paint... I also spent some time tracking down the various rattles in the car. The main heatshield rattle turned out not to be a heatshield but a panel in the boot that covers the fuel tank filler neck that was a little loose. Two bolts torqued up and the biggest noise in the car has gone! There is still a rattle in the drivetrain under low speed acceleration and higher speed deceleration - this sounds exactly like the PPF misalignment noise which people have limited success in fixing. Definitely needs fixing, although it seems to be slowly fixing itslef - either that or I'm subconciously driving around it. Finally, I got a lot more awl practice in... The rest of the previously repaired seam in the soft top decided to give up completley as I zipped the window back in one evening, the only bits holding the rear window in were my previous repairs! Gah. Mostly finished stitching it back up, I'll get a photo once it's complete. So far two of the three main things that I thought made up the cars value when I bought it have failed - torsen and mohair roof! Maybe this car wasn't such a good buy after all! The brakes were the third thing - they feel really nice but currently squeal like hell - need to get some copper slip in there.
|
|
Last Edit: Jun 2, 2020 10:53:11 GMT by gryphon
|
|
gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
|
I hadn't realised the pictures in the last post hadn't worked... All fixed now! Couple of updates. Firstly the rear window is all stitched back in. The only bits holding it in were the two areas I'd previously fixed and about a foot of stitching around the top right corner that was coming loose at the slightest tug: A few hours with the awl and it was looking a little better. I still wish it wasn't contrast stitching, but I got it mostly straight! While I was doing softtop bits, the once black screw heads holding the latches to it had turned white with corrosion and stood out like a sore thumb inside. Taking them all out, cleaning them, and giving them a quick spray of satin black paint smartened up the interior a surprising ammount - now it's the latches that really let it down, but they're harder to 'fix'. One of those improvements that's nice because it's something you don't notice any more, rather than anything you actively think looks good... Going back a month or so, I started looking at fitting low profile headlights before realising I didn't have all the parts. I looked at making them myself, but also emailed Jass Performance who made the kit in the first place (I bought it second hand). They were very happy to send out the bits I needed for a fair price, so I took that route. Old lights out: Look at all that new space in the engine bay! While the lights were out I was able to get some photos of engine-bonnet clearance, or lack thereof. It is toight in there! Oil filler just misses the bonet stiffening structure and sits about 2mm from the bonnet skin. On the other bank the intake plenum has milimeters of clearance to the bonnet, and the filter is pressed up against it - I've angled it down a little more but not going to be able to get it to fully clear. There goes the idea of getting a different non-foam style of filter. Anyway, onwards with the lights. New link arms for the popup mechanism bolted in place. Had to drill new holes, then prime and paint to protect the bared steel: Hella 4x6" units bolted onto the old frames And excuse the lack of pictures... All bolted in! I'm not quite sure if the car looks 'suspiscious' or just a little bit ill now. (and not ill in a good way!) Previously I thought the 4x6 units were a little bit rx7 esque - now they're on I don't really think so any more. Never mind though, the important view is this one: Nice and subtle from behind the wheel Next up I've ordered 4 new tyres for the superleggera wheels. Went for Yoko AD08RS', new RS versions get mixed reviews but we shall see. I've also ordered a full set of IL Motorsport suspension bushes as after almost 300 miles, then comparing it to the other MX5, the ride on the polybushes is too clunky, and also there is a definite knock from the front right that sounds quite bushy. Once they're in I will see if I like the dampers which feel a little bouncy to me compared to the meisterrs on the other car. Change those out or stick with the HSDs, then finally get a proper cornerweight and geo. I'm also still trying to decide what to do about the diff. Apparently the 3.3:1 CROWN and pinion you can buy from MFactory has a significant whine to it, which puts me off a little, but it's the only way to get down to decent cruising RPMs - on the off chance anyone has any experience with it I'd welcome any feedback! I'm also looking at the Blackline ATB differential core - at only about £100 more than a used Torsen would cost me it seems stupid not to - but at the same time it's all getting pricey!
|
|
|
|
Porsche
West Midlands
Kev from B'ham.
Posts: 4,725
|
|
|
I'm not quite sure if the car looks 'suspiscious' or just a little bit ill now. (and not ill in a good way!) Previously I thought the 4x6 units were a little bit rx7 esque - now they're on I don't really think so any more. Never mind though, the important view is this one: I see what you mean about the car looking ill. It's not the headlights though, it's the offset number plate. It looks like a thermometer in it's mouth. I like the lights and would keep them if this car was mine. Maybe get a square number plate fitted? (Like in the below photo).
|
|
Last Edit: Jun 2, 2020 11:43:59 GMT by Porsche
|
|
gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
|
haha, I hadn't seen the thermometer!
You might be right. I was going to order an import style plate but never got round to it. Stuck the old one on and didn't think it looked too bad so it dropped right down the priority list.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
PAnd finally there is a best of all worlds/empty your wallet option that I found courtesy of BOFI racing...Which is a 3.3:1 ratio CROWN and pinion (have only found new for too much money) and a 6-speed gearbox which keeps gears 1-5 in line with what they currently are in my 5 speed with 4.1 diff, then a nice overdrive 6th gear with 70mph cruising under 3k rpm. I really like this solution if I can get the cost down, as I now think the remaining driveline noises have to be from the gearbox and 6 gears appeal... My brother in law is very good friends with BOFI and has pretty much a catalogue build with their 3.3 diff and 6 speed...and many many go faster bits. If you follow them on Facebook or Instagram it's the nardo grey one they're featuring at the moment. I can't remember if the 3.3 was in it when I last drove it but he absolutely loves it and says it's by far one of the best additions. If you have any questions send me a PM and I'll pass on the message or put you in touch. Following this with interest, always had a V6 swap in the back of my mind. I've now committed another chunk of money to mine so when finished all I'll have left to do is a respray and engine work...seems silly not to
|
|
Project Diary1975 Viva / 1988 T25 Camper / 1989 Mini / 1991 MX5 / 1992 Mini / 1994 Saab 9000 / 1997 Saab 9000 / 2008 Saab 9-5
|
|
gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
|
My brother in law is very good friends with BOFI and has pretty much a catalogue build with their 3.3 diff and 6 speed...and many many go faster bits. If you follow them on Facebook or Instagram it's the nardo grey one they're featuring at the moment. I can't remember if the 3.3 was in it when I last drove it but he absolutely loves it and says it's by far one of the best additions. If you have any questions send me a PM and I'll pass on the message or put you in touch. Following this with interest, always had a V6 swap in the back of my mind. I've now committed another chunk of money to mine so when finished all I'll have left to do is a respray and engine work...seems silly not to Thanks. I'd not seen that build, looks excellent though! Would be great to hear if there is any whine from the diff - and what diff bushings that's with. The videos I've seen range from sounding like a noisy straight cut box to a faint supercharger whine. Silly not to indeed And on that note Rocketeer has started taking orders for kits again...
|
|
|
|
gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
|
I had a quick chat with BOFI and they haven't found any whine from the 3.3 C+P in any of their builds which is encouraging. The cynic in me says that 'they would say that, they're trying to sell them', but they also said that the blackline diff has had some complaints from customers. The splines on the MX5 driveshafts have a loose circlip around them about a 3rd of the way in which locates in a detent in the splines in the diff, holding the driveshafts lateral position. The blackline diff doesn't have this detent in the diff output splines, and as such the driveshaft isn't held laterally and ends up pushing too far in and the driveshaft scrapes against the diff housing. I imagine a PET or Nylon washer between the driveshaft and the housing would get rid of the noise and as it shouldn't be loaded might even last decently, but it puts me off the blackline diff a little. I dismantled my dead T2 Torsen over the weekend to see what I could see... (Pictures as promised scimitarse6b ) I wasn't sure what to expect but from the reading up I'd done on the CROWN and pinion contact patch, this was bigger that I'd expected: The contact patch appears to cover most of the face... As the backlash was in spec I guess the wear wasn't too bad though. Once the centre was out I had a go at pulling off the bearings. The design of the diff only allows a 2 prong puller, and I only have a very cheap set of 2 prong pullers. I've got the centre of the puller located on a deep groove ball bearing (I think it's an old spigot bearing from the 944). This gives a good axis for the puller shaft to rotate on and helps stop it wondering off to the side as 2 prong pullers so like to do. Somehow I don't think they were ever designed for use with a breaker bar though... That went with quite a bang! Much to my surprise I flipped the puller arm around and actually managed to get that bearing off. The opposite one was definitely not budging though and the thread on the puller rounded before it budged. Now I need to buy a more expensive puller! Bearings only need to come off if I'm replacing them though - and in hindsight I'm not sure I needed to pull it off at all. I can keep pulling the rest of it apart with the bearing in place. CROWN gear off: Fine threaded bolts with lots of locktite - took the breaker bar just to screw them out. Two more little screws to come out that were JIS heads instead of philips. Luckily I have a set of JIS bits as they were very tight and I wouldn't be surprised if a phillips just rounded them. So the magical insides of a T2 Torsen diff. Apologies for the blurry pictures - oil on my phone camera lens again :/ So, how does that lot work? When you google torsen diffs, they come up with quite a different internal structure. I may be talking out my [fox picture] here, but my understanding was that Torsen is just a trademarked name (Tor queSen sing) and this diffs workings are more inline with every other ATB (Auto Torque Biasing) diff out there. When both wheels are spinning at the same speed the helical geared shafts aren't spinning relative to the output shafts. When there is a speed differential, these shafts start turning, and due to the helical nature of the gears force the output shafts towards the wheel that's spinning faster, where they push against the square patterned bronze(?) bush, generating friction effectively braking that wheel and sending more torque to the slower wheel as a result. So, why is mine creating a load of driveline lash and sounding like a bag of spanners? I've no way of measuring the wear on the helical gears, but they all look in decent shape, no missing bits. The only way I can see of generating lash is if the output shafts are moving too much laterally: And for that to happen, the possibly bronze bushes at each end of the diff would have to be worn. From the pictures it looks like the loaded centre sections of the bushes look more worn than the locating 'ears'... I'd hazard a guess I've found my problem but as I worked all this out by sleeping on it I've not got back out to the garage to take a second look at the parts. So my options now... I need to measure the worn section in comparison with the unworn area to give me an idea of how worn the bushes are compared to original spec. I'll try this with my cheapy DTI, but I might also be able to make use of a proper measuring table and calibrated DTI at work. I don't think I'll be able to find a spec for the exact alloy those bushes are made from, which I imagine is quite important to get the correct coefficient of friction between the surfaces, so having new bushes machined might be difficult, although I imagine I could take a stab at material choice by looking at what other ATB differentials use. The easier option might be to add a shim behind the bush. There is already one shim there. If I can add a shim to each side equal to the measured wear on each bush my head says 'job done'. Might need to then take down the material on the locating flanges to stop the helical geared shafts catching on them, but that's easy enough. The issue is that there's no spec I can find for this. On one forum post I found the nugget that the clearance inside the pumpkin with everything assembled should be 10-15 thousandths, so I'll see if I can work out how to measure that... I'll get some measurements and talk to a friendly machinist and get a second opinion. Then I need to work out if I want to go through all the faff of setting the backlash and refitting this diff to the car to test a fix that may or may not work!
|
|
Last Edit: Jun 9, 2020 10:12:16 GMT by gryphon
|
|
gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
|
Well, pictures lie. Got a micrometer on the bushes today: Total wear appears to be 0.09mm. I'll put it back together and measure the gap using the spec found floating around on the internet, but given the amount of play and noise I was feeling, 0.09mm wear seems to small to cause that. On the other hand in worst case it could put it up to 39% over tolerance... so maybe?? If it's not that then I don't have a clue what it is. Ideas welcome ! While the diff is in bits I decided to make a start on the suspension as the set of rubber bushes arrived over the weekend to replace the polybushes. It looks like the rear suspension has been apart a few years ago for a spruce up and fitting the polybushes so I wasn't expecting it to put up too much of a fight... How wrong I was. It's far more stubborn than the Dakar was after sitting for 8 years! Suspension bolts came out ok, but the driveshaft would not push out of the hub. Thankfully my three prong puller is an old solid one, better than my cheapo two prong ones! Got it! Oh, wait... That puller has actually already snapped and been welded on another leg in the past as you can see.... I need new pullers all round it seems - and I still can't budge the driveshaft. Left it soaking in 50:50 ATF:Acetone and I'll see if I can beg/borrow/steal the next puller to break. Also look at the end of the driveshaft... I'm not the first person to have trouble getting it out of the hub, it's been whacked pretty hard in the past!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
When I had a to get a shaft out of my XJS which resisted every puller I could find I got hold of an old steel wheel and the biggest nut and bolt I could find (around M30) welded the nut in the centre of the wheel, bolted the wheel to the hub and tightened the greased M30 bolt up as tight as I could, smacked it with a lump hammer and it moved a tiny bit, kept repeating this until it came free.
|
|
|
|
gryphon
Club Retro Rides Member
Posts: 330
Club RR Member Number: 157
|
|
|
That sounds like a hefty custom puller. Luckily I've been able to borrow an 8 tonne hydraulic one so I should be able to crack on with it tonight. Hopefully not literally.
|
|
|
|
|