Adey
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,442
Club RR Member Number: 171
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Adey
@adey1984
Club Retro Rides Member 171
|
Jul 26, 2020 20:48:15 GMT
|
can you fit mechanical fan as well as electric one? Unfortunately not, in both the dauphine and r8 they have a fan bolted to the water pump but at opposite ends of the engine. Mine now has the water pump at the wrong end of the engine to match with the rad location. If i fit a fan to this it would end up through the boot lid and theres no space for a rad at the rear of my car.
|
|
|
|
|
Adey
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,442
Club RR Member Number: 171
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Adey
@adey1984
Club Retro Rides Member 171
|
Jul 26, 2020 20:52:22 GMT
|
jonsey They are more central than the pic shows though slightly different front to rear. The outer pairs seem offset to each other, the liners look to be machined to touch but the inner 2 don't have flats on them and a bigger gap. Ill have a mull over it and decide if i should try a better rad or move it up front
|
|
Last Edit: Jul 26, 2020 20:55:33 GMT by Adey
|
|
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine peteh1969
@peteh1969
Club Retro Rides Member 107
|
Jul 26, 2020 21:03:29 GMT
|
It could be that the rad is too big and it is not helping the flow of the water and it is pooling in the rad rather than flowing through causing it to boil in an area rather than cool.
|
|
|
|
drseg
Part of things
Posts: 142
|
|
Jul 26, 2020 21:20:37 GMT
|
i'm suspecting rad lash up old one and see if that changes things
|
|
|
|
Adey
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,442
Club RR Member Number: 171
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Adey
@adey1984
Club Retro Rides Member 171
|
Jul 26, 2020 21:46:14 GMT
|
i'm suspecting rad lash up old one and see if that changes things My concern is that old rad was designed for half the hp and had a fan constantly pulling through it and way undersized for this application. I'll dig it out tomorrow and give it a clean. Need to wait on a new HG before I can test anything.
|
|
|
|
drseg
Part of things
Posts: 142
|
|
Jul 26, 2020 22:59:45 GMT
|
i'm thinking not a forever job just to see if it flows air and cools better than ally one which may be acting like a solid wall by comparison
as has been said fan too small and slow as well can't help
originally was the heater full flow all the time? anything different with the flow there?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Our VWs from the mid 2000s have a secondary water pump inline, I think to help circulate coolant after the car shuts off....could something like that be of use if you can hook it to a thermostat switch to turn on when the thermostat opens?
I guess you could even hook a small led light to it to show you that it is working when switched on....
JP
|
|
I know its spelled Norman Luxury Yacht, but its pronounced Throat Wobbler Mangrove!
|
|
Phil H
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,448
Club RR Member Number: 133
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Phil H
@philhoward
Club Retro Rides Member 133
|
|
Its a generic flat blade type, looks like a china special and i have my doubts its actually a 6v fan. Was sold as a fan that can go in either direction but no idea tbh Back to the electric fan - can’t say I’ve come across a 6v one so expect it to be a special? Assuming it’s controlled by a thernoswitch does the fan come on and stay or or settle down to a cycle of on for 10 seconds, off for 20 or the like? Have you got a link to the one you’ve got?
|
|
Last Edit: Jul 27, 2020 6:24:41 GMT by Phil H
|
|
Adey
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,442
Club RR Member Number: 171
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Adey
@adey1984
Club Retro Rides Member 171
|
|
Ill dig it out, came from somewhere in the states (china). Part number was 910151-12 brand was speedway from my notes. When it turned up it just looked like a generic china fan and i was pretty gutted tbh but i waited quite a while from point of order to receiving it. It runs on a thermo switch and at idle will get up to temp and run for a minute about 1m40 after running a while then back off again, but it seems slow, making me think its actually just a 12v fan running at half speed (and the fact its identical to a generic no special packing, plain cardboard box).
As jonsey has said its probably an airflow issue, the oem had a mechanical fan always running, mine doesnt. Most put the rads up front, ive kept it out back (must be for a good reason) I was probably a bit naive to think i could do it this way when nearly every pic of an engine swapped one has the radiators upfront.
I cant see adding an electrical water pump helping as if i cant get the air flow too cool it all i will be doing is circulating the water more, my temperature issue is when driving also, when at idle it seems to behave.
Should of just gone with what everyone else has done and switch to 12v and fit the rad up front from the start but whats the fun in that lol. 12v to run a decent fan and rad up front for better flow.
|
|
|
|
Paul Y
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,951
|
|
|
Having experienced, well not over heating but running very hot, with my 56 I can feel your frustration. Easy to be an armchair engineer but before you start moving rads etc can I make a few suggestions based on what I did to cure my ills? Had a look at your pictures during one of my numerous CC's and cant make out some of the details so apologies if you have already done this. 1. Airflow through the rad - Is it completely sealed so that air entering from the fronts only route is through the radiator itself? 2. Put a shroud around the fan, sealing it, so that actually draws air across the radiator - at the moment the fan is doing very little. 3. Get hot air out of the engine bay - did the raised deck lid make a difference? 4. Tuning - already covered. Did the advance make a difference? 5. Collapsed hoses - are any of the pipes collapsing internally when it gets hot restricting flow. The biggest reduction in engine temp on the Orange car was achieved by sealing the rad, ducting the fans and then giving the air somewhere to escape. Went from over 200 driving down the road to never getting above 195 whilst sitting in traffic on the M25 on a 30degree plus day. Naturally I did all this after spending nearly £1000 on a super radiator, different pulleys for the water pump, upgraded water pump, very expensive twin Spalls fans with magic controllers etc etc. None of it made a difference until I did the above, it just took longer to get hot! Keep going, nearly there. P.
|
|
|
|
Adey
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,442
Club RR Member Number: 171
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Adey
@adey1984
Club Retro Rides Member 171
|
|
lol no worries I'm all ears for ideas on how to help it run normally.
1. Airflow in either goes through the rad or back under the car but fully sealed off around it. (current theory is it doesn't allow the air through it with its low flow/pressure location to actually cool)
2. Good idea but the issue is heat build up when driving, ideally i don't want the fan to fun all the time to keep it cool, at idle the fan though slow seems to be able to keep it at a constant normal temp between 92c and 82c? wouldn't ducting the fan just help when the fan is running?
3. The rear of the engine bay is unobstructed with massive vents, propping the decklid didn't seem to make any difference to running temp once heat had built up.
4. No notable difference once it build up temp on the move, it seems to retain heat until pushing the water out of the header tank.
5. The only way ive been able to check this, and i have, was to rev the engine as high as i could whilst not moving. I did it cold and hot to see if it was an issue with the stat both open and closed. No hoses were collapsing when doing so.
|
|
Last Edit: Jul 27, 2020 9:09:08 GMT by Adey
|
|
Phil H
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,448
Club RR Member Number: 133
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Phil H
@philhoward
Club Retro Rides Member 133
|
|
Temperature is regulated by the thermostat- you can fit a lower temperature switch for the fan if you like but you would normally set it to hold just above “normal” running temperature according to the gauge. No point setting it lower as all it will do it start to close the thermostat again.
Running times sound about right (not marvellous but OK) - there’s only so much juice you can pull from a 6V system anyway and it does look like a “genuine” 6V fan from the links I've found from a quick google. Are you running it relayed straight off the battery?
Ducting is king though when it comes to getting conventional (moving) airflow, even if you try and seal the edges around the rad to its periphery with some aluminium tape as air will take any route aside from through a radiator core given the chance.
|
|
|
|
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine peteh1969
@peteh1969
Club Retro Rides Member 107
|
|
Smaller rad, fan on water pump pulley and move the rad to the back where the vents are and there is room.
You will get air moving over the engine and the rad and straight out.
|
|
|
|
Phil H
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,448
Club RR Member Number: 133
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Phil H
@philhoward
Club Retro Rides Member 133
|
Jul 27, 2020 10:01:17 GMT
|
Being rear engined though it may require continual forced air movement and can’t rely on ram air (as you would if the rad was up front); not a problem with an engine driven fan of course..
Closest analogy I can think of is an Imp where it used to have an engine driven fan (and a tiny rad) except I can’t recall of the rad being retained in its usual location and losing the engine fan - it’s normally accompanied by moving the rad to the front..
|
|
|
|
Phil H
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,448
Club RR Member Number: 133
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Phil H
@philhoward
Club Retro Rides Member 133
|
Jul 27, 2020 10:02:26 GMT
|
Smaller rad, fan on water pump pulley and move the rad to the back where the vents are and there is room. You will get air moving over the engine and the rad and straight out. Hasn’t it already been mentioned if you fitted a fan to the new pump pulley it would need holes chopping in the lid?
|
|
|
|
Phil H
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,448
Club RR Member Number: 133
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Phil H
@philhoward
Club Retro Rides Member 133
|
Jul 27, 2020 10:03:28 GMT
|
can you fit mechanical fan as well as electric one? Unfortunately not, in both the dauphine and r8 they have a fan bolted to the water pump but at opposite ends of the engine. Mine now has the water pump at the wrong end of the engine to match with the rad location. If i fit a fan to this it would end up through the boot lid and theres no space for a rad at the rear of my car.
|
|
|
|
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine peteh1969
@peteh1969
Club Retro Rides Member 107
|
Jul 27, 2020 10:12:38 GMT
|
Doesn't have to be a big fan as on the Invcar that works because it has to pull the air through and over the engine a similar thing can be done here but forced through the rad.
It works for a Betetle as well all the same principles.
|
|
Last Edit: Jul 27, 2020 10:14:59 GMT by peteh1969
|
|
Adey
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,442
Club RR Member Number: 171
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Adey
@adey1984
Club Retro Rides Member 171
|
Jul 27, 2020 10:31:20 GMT
|
Being rear engined though it may require continual forced air movement and can’t rely on ram air (as you would if the rad was up front); not a problem with an engine driven fan of course.. Closest analogy I can think of is an Imp where it used to have an engine driven fan (and a tiny rad) except I can’t recall of the rad being retained in its usual location and losing the engine fan - it’s normally accompanied by moving the rad to the front.. i think this is where i have dropped the ball going against whats normally done......
|
|
|
|
Phil H
Posted a lot
Posts: 1,448
Club RR Member Number: 133
|
The 1957 "The Dope" Dauphine Phil H
@philhoward
Club Retro Rides Member 133
|
Jul 27, 2020 20:41:55 GMT
|
I fear you may have identified the root cause of the problem - but alternatively you could have found the magic solution the masses had simply declared impossible and without trying it you wouldn’t know. Just because “that’s how it’s always been done”,,doesn’t mean there isn’t a better way/new solution out there.
|
|
Last Edit: Jul 27, 2020 20:42:51 GMT by Phil H
|
|
|
|
|
kind of a dumb thought here.....any way to push hot air OUT the vents in the back of the engine bay? could that be used to somehow pull air through the radiator and across the motor and out the back?
had a strange visual of ducting that scoop under the car to each side under the sills and just in front of the rear wheels. the ducts could be disguised as exhaust tips.....
sorry, its been a long day...and a really hot one!
you'll figure it out, and maybe find a "new" way to cool the transplant.....
JP
|
|
I know its spelled Norman Luxury Yacht, but its pronounced Throat Wobbler Mangrove!
|
|