ChasR
RR Helper
motivation
Posts: 10,251
Club RR Member Number: 170
|
|
|
I shall be indeedy. I shall bang on the new mount setup and see how I fare. Whilst it is arguably superior to how the original item is mounted you never know how it could affect the vibration.
I shall after that be making a trip down to the gearbox place to get the play in the tailshaft sorted. It will either be a worn spline to where the output lflange bolts onto the tailshaft (apparently tightening can sort this) or it will be a shot bearing in the tailshaft extension.
|
|
Last Edit: Mar 5, 2012 20:43:31 GMT by ChasR
|
|
|
ChasR
RR Helper
motivation
Posts: 10,251
Club RR Member Number: 170
|
|
Mar 14, 2012 19:30:37 GMT
|
Well, I have tried to proceed further with the vibration hunting, so I started to work my way through other areas. One suspect area was the gearbox mounting and crossmember. The bushes were partially missing in addition to being over tightened. Also the gearbox mounts were not in great order (one was quite soft and both were distorted as a result of being 'made to fit). The new bushes are on the outside. In their distorted form they fitted the crossmember quite poorly like this: So a new bracket was made: As you can see one bush was missing (about a 1/4 of it was left on the car, and none of them had their nylon spacers with the bushes all being deformed and playful affairs). New bushes were purchased. Only a slight difference...: After all that, how does it drive? Still bloody vibrates as soon as you hit 50, although as before it vibrates slightly when you put your foot down from about 30mph onwards. Time to look at the gearbox flange (I am sure it was tight before and it does look as if it is loose so I shall attempt to tighten that) and to try getting the propshaft balanced. Balls. To cheer me up, I decided to whack on some new wheels onto the car. The vibration has gone down with this but the core vibration is still present. The bumper was off so as to remove a snapped bolt from before me buying the car. Damn this thing.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mar 14, 2012 20:53:09 GMT
|
With a bit of lows, I think that would look spot on with the rimmage and no bumper! (If the valance was painted white as well )
|
|
|
|
ChasR
RR Helper
motivation
Posts: 10,251
Club RR Member Number: 170
|
|
|
Believe me, dropping the car has been near the top of the list for quite some time, but other issues (I.e The vibration) take priority over it. Regarding that, my mojo has been on the ups and downs on this car. Ups when on the country roads cruising down at 50MPH or driving in town, down when I see the oil marks from the leaking diff on the drive in addition to a clonking exhaust (not hung up properly on the subframe and blowing in places (wrong clamps), or on a dual carriageway (where I near enough have to) doing a sedate 55MPH thanks to that sodding vibration. On the plus side I seem to know lorry drivers better and all that headlight flashing business LOL. So with that in mine, and the sun being out, I figured it was time I made a start on correcting that, and so I proceeded to take away various parts that would allow me to drop the subframe down, so as to change the diff and extension housing. Before I went about doing any of that, I changed a tired universal joint for a GKN item in the driveshaft. Whilst it made part of the drive smoother, the vibration was still there (if anything it is noticed more as the car becomes a smoother drive). Off first was part of the exhaust system (it passes through the subframe itself (round holes are visible in the front part): And it's off! Next was the propshaft. Remember this speedo ring? When Rob and I drove this car with the gear selector removed so as to see how the gearbox and propshaft were behaving we noticed that the speedo ring threw out the propshaft about 1/2 to maybe 1mm outside of the true. In the vibration zone the propshaft did not shake or vibrate so it was not seen as a cause for concern. But on the basis that it could cause some issues off it came. This turned out to be fun, with screwdriver not even budging the ring off the propshaft flange, so I had to resort to other measures: And the ring is off! I have indexed everything just in case but it probably is not necessary (it might even improve things LOL). I did notice that the holes for the bolts were larger in the ring but again I did not see this as a cause for concern. The prop shall now be taken back to Dave Mac Props to see if it is out of balance. Whilst I took that off, it appears that my nosecone bearing is not in the best of health with some play present, and well, being the source of the leaking gear oil. Later on the in the week the subframe shall be dropped off and the new diff and nosecone (reinforced with a new extension housing (nosecone) bearing) shall be fitted once the coil springs, brake flexi hoses and handbrake cables are removed. Another thing I noticed was that the diff when turning one of the output flanges (with the other output flange and input locked off) is that when I turn it to get rid of the backlash it stops (like the other diff (less is present in the other) and then it creeps on slightly more to another stop. When reversing and turning (and sometimes when taking a tight corner when going forwards) it does seem to bind slightly. Whether this is the UJs (they are all free) is another thing, but again we shall see what it's like.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
looking good Mr C
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Good luck Chas! Any chance it will be done before the housewarming There are some lovely roads through the Cotswolds on your drive down
|
|
|
|
ChasR
RR Helper
motivation
Posts: 10,251
Club RR Member Number: 170
|
|
|
Maybe, just maybe. If the weather stays good I am hoping that it will be completed by the end of the week!
You're not kidding about the roads! When I went to Northleach the other day in the Mondeo I could not resist opening that up, I mean dawdling down. Fingers crossed it can be done in the Stag.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Note that the quill shaft bearing is a sealed-for-life greased ball-race. It is not supposed to see the diff oil at all. In fact diff oil, leaking from the front seal washes the grease out and causes the bearing to fail. To stop the oil leak you have to fit a new oil seal into the nose of the diff itself. Many will tell you get the original type leather seals but in my experience the modern double-lipped rubber ones work much better. Getting the old seal out (especially the leather ones) can be a trying process!
Just a suggestion, but on re-assembly, why not try running the car up to speed on axle stands before you connect up the driveshafts (do put oil in the diff first!). Then you will know, if you get still vibration, that it has nothing to do with the driveshafts or rear wheels. You could also try balancing the prop on the car with two jubilee clips, which is the only way I've ever been able to eliminate propshaft vibration on my Vitesse.
If you find you are vibration-free, then fit the driveshafts without the brake drums and try again.
Good luck!
Nick
|
|
1967 Triumph Vitesse convertible (old friend) 1996 Audi A6 2.5 TDI Avant (still durability testing) 1972 GT6 Mk3 (Restored after loong rest & getting the hang of being a car again)
|
|
ChasR
RR Helper
motivation
Posts: 10,251
Club RR Member Number: 170
|
|
|
I am so glad that you said that Nick! A number of enthusiasts told me that I should have gone with another leather seal when I was reinforcing my extension housing (and changing the bearing), but as stated I have fitted a more modern rubber seal which my local specialist claimed to be fine on many cars he has fitted them with (on other cars, the seals have been fine too!). You weren't kidding about taking the seal out either! I did persevere and manage to get it out. Regarding the stand idea I sort of did that already. With the prop off I gingerly took the car into 4th gear and revved it gently and at a higher speed than it ever has done in 4th. Zero vibrations whatsover. When the car was being coasted down a hill with zero accelerator, the vibrations did start at, yep you guessed it, 55MPH. But yes. I will give the stand idea a go once the rear is reassembled, via jacking up the rear suspension with the stands under the trailing arms (with blocks of wood to spread the weight . Cheers again, and fingers crossed I can put this vibration to bed once and for all.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I meant that you should do this with the prop in place and spinning the diff, but without the shafts. The prop is a strong suspect. I think you have changed this already (?) but I've been there with my Vitesse, which vibrated whatever I did (new orientations, new joints even complete new prop) until I balanced it on the car with jubilee clips.
On my PI I had a nasty vibration which was largely cured when I discovered (by chance, when refitting the gearbox) that the front prop UJ flange had the bolt holes and centralising spigot on considerably different centres (like 3mm different!) with the result that you could either have the spigot fully drop into the recess in the gearbox flange or put the bolts in - but never both. Witness marks on the gearbox flange suggested that although I wasn't the first to spot that there was a problem, I was the first to figure out what it was (took a while though!). So don't go assuming any of the parts were made right in the first place......
Another thing to watch out for is whether the hub flanges run true. They are so damn tight on the stubs through the wheelbearing that they often get injured on removal causing wobbly wheels and bad vibes.....
Nick
|
|
1967 Triumph Vitesse convertible (old friend) 1996 Audi A6 2.5 TDI Avant (still durability testing) 1972 GT6 Mk3 (Restored after loong rest & getting the hang of being a car again)
|
|
|
ChasR
RR Helper
motivation
Posts: 10,251
Club RR Member Number: 170
|
|
|
Are any of you familiar with the feeling of the feeling of 'I told you so'? I was over the past two days! I left this thread saying how I was planning on bringing forward the rear end strip now that the weather seemed a little warmer, and how I sent the propshaft off to Dave Mac Propshafts (where it was confirmed it was one of his own). Yesterday morning I had a call from him. With the trigger wheel in place they said it would not be possible to balance the propshaft since it was being thrown off balance that much. Without it, the propshaft was shown to need not much doing to it in order to balance it, so it was balanced without the speedo trigger wheel. Today I bolted on the propshaft and part of the exhaust for a road test before I went about stripping the rear diff of the car etc. Suffice to say I can now drive the car anywhere at near enough any speed! There is still a very slight rumble (well, in terms of sound present) which I am assuming is the shot nosecone bearing and a lack of exhaust mounts of the subframe, but wow, what a difference. Dare I say it, it is probably the first time in a while this car has been capable of doing motorway work. It is actually quite a serene experience now at 60mph . Of course this does now mean that I shall have to keep an eye out for speed cameras in addition to resorting to another way of getting a working speedometer, especially before MOT time arrives.
|
|
|
|
luckygti
Posted a lot
I need to try harder!
Posts: 4,912
|
|
|
Brilliant news Chas, sure this must ahve been getting you down. Such a great lloking car as well. I'm sure you've said somewhere, but why the speedo trigger wheel. On a kit car cobra I had I'm pretty sure it was similar to what's on my push bike? Might be an easier option?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Great news
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Great stuff! Those wheels really suit it.
|
|
|
|
MrSpeedy
East Midlands
www.vintagediesels.co.uk
Posts: 4,789
|
|
|
Splendid news I too am plagued by vibration at around 60 mph and have always suspected my propshaft tbh, many cos it's one I cobbled together when I did the 'box conversion and it's never been balanced
|
|
|
|
andyborris
Posted a lot
Freedom is just another word for nothing left to lose.
Posts: 2,214
|
|
|
Hurray and well done for sticking with it! And sorted in time for summer, a Stags natural environment. I think you don't need a speedo for a MOT and if you need to know how fast you're going, use a Sat Nav?
|
|
|
|
ChasR
RR Helper
motivation
Posts: 10,251
Club RR Member Number: 170
|
|
|
Thanks alot of for your kind comments. This problem was frustrating to say the least, and now it has gone I really can see the point of the ZF 4HP22 gearbox setup in the car! It is a joy to drive around town and on the motorway it is unlike any other standard auto Stag. In 4th gear and lockup drive engaged 2,500rpm arrives at 70MPH with 3,000rpm being 80MPH, if the GPS speedo is to be believed. It becomes such a relaxed car the motorway, suiting the character of the car so well. To my surprise it actually pulls very well in 4th+lockup too . Brilliant news Chas, sure this must ahve been getting you down. Such a great lloking car as well. I'm sure you've said somewhere, but why the speedo trigger wheel. On a kit car cobra I had I'm pretty sure it was similar to what's on my push bike? Might be an easier option? Thanks muchly, and it was not getting me down *that* much, honest... When I acquired the car it seems the PO had attempted a few things at trying to get the speedo working. The rear of the prop had an optical sensor and a thin copper trigger plate put in between the diff and prop flanges. At the front was the ring that I have now removed. From what I could tell, the ring was being used with an unknown speedo sensor from a Ford with a motor attached to the back of the original speedo. Bar the fact that I needed a chip to make the two items work together (with a 10V stabilized output the most that speedo could go to is 110MPH) meant that this car has never had a working speedometer in my ownership. With the trigger rings miles out of alignment I have also scrapped the idea of reusing that setup (that a Ford sensor being around £80 new if it does go bang in addition to the motor being a little loud when going above 50MPH). Indeed I plan to go down the magnetic bolt/pickup route similar to what you had on your Cobra. Smiths do such a kit that is proven to work (an LED esque speedo pickup using a magnetic bolt and a new speedometer) but at £200 I am wondering if it can be done cheaper, so if push comes to shove I may end up having to buy that setup before the next MOT. Hurray and well done for sticking with it! And sorted in time for summer, a Stags natural environment. I think you don't need a speedo for a MOT and if you need to know how fast you're going, use a Sat Nav? Indeed, it does seem like I have overcome a large hurdle in getting the road to what I would say is roadworthy! For the new regulations I understand the car will need a working speedometer, in addition to lacking split rubber boots and a battery clamp As a little celebratory thing for making the car more drivable I figured I would take some photos of it as the car is now. I have changed a couple of things on it, but there is still quite a bit to do. The main areas of note are the hard top, and also the altitude problem on the rear now I have fitted the near enough correct diameter tyres on. At least the arch gap is not as crazy as it was before.
|
|
Last Edit: Apr 6, 2012 12:36:05 GMT by ChasR
|
|
|
|
|
Number plates looking really smart Chas!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
cars can be such a headache, your vibration issue a case in point! Car is looking great, and those recent pictures gave me a thought that I thought to pass on: the rear panel the lights sit in could easily be painted to match the hardtop and might look okay. Of course, it could also look terrible I'll be interested to read about how you fix the speedo, this is one of those threads that I learn quite a bit from.
|
|
|
|
ChasR
RR Helper
motivation
Posts: 10,251
Club RR Member Number: 170
|
|
Apr 16, 2012 22:04:33 GMT
|
To be fair Volksangyl the rear panel should be black being a MkII Stag (Mk1s were body coloured). I guess during the respray this point was somewhat overlooked! Hmmm, blue instead of the black! I was having thoughts about the hardtop colours instead of the usual body coloured items oddly enough (Satin black with white quarterlight apertures). I still have both of the speedometer setups (the metal trigger wheel and the optical pickup with a disc (but this was ditched by PO by the looks of it probably down to dirt ingress messing things up!). Hopefully I will arrive with a feasible solution. Anyway, with a car I can now drive I took it to a show at Longbridge: I still need to cure other small vibrations and tidy up the rest of the interior but at least I am going in the right direction .
|
|
|
|
|