ianmk2
Part of things
Posts: 116
|
|
|
Good afternoon all,
Long time lurker, quite a rare poster, but I have recently availed myself of another 'classic' so that may change.
I have previously dabbled in it with a Mk2 Fiesta, however things between me and it didn't really work out, I lost interest fairly quickly because it had no purpose in my life other than 'being an old car' so I sold it. (I intend for the Granada to have a purpose as a tow vehicle, providing the autobox doesn't explode)
Annnnyhoo, I had always secretly wanted a Granada, a Mk2 if I'm honest because that's what my Dad had when I was growing up - and who doesn't want the car their dad had? But a Mk2 of the standard I would want is £4-5k upwards and I didn't have that much to spend. Luckily my Dad also had a Mk3 so those are the footsteps I have followed in, although his was only a puny 2.0 which I didn't love anywhere near as much, so I have rectified that by buying the 24V 'Cossie' - which is the one I wanted him to buy
So without further a do, this is her on the day I picked her up
The photo does her more justice than she really deserves, there are a few dings and scrapes, but the overall appearance is clean, wheels are good, MOT history is good and tin worm hasn't really taken too much of a hold on her. The bad? Well, 221,000 miles, but I'm not going to let that worry me, I had a 240,000 mile Mondeo previous to this and it was the 2nd most reliable car I've ever owned.
However I do not go into car purchases completely blind, so I had done some homework and read about the common issues, weak gearboxes, cam chain tensioners, cam chain tensioner blades, everything cam chain related...What I can tell you immediately is that it does have an issue with no 4th gear (I am working on it) but the cam chain sounds fine at all times, no rattle on startup.
So the last few nights have been spent diagnosing 4th gear, the most common issue here is the Vehicle Speed Sensor which is located in the back of the gearbox, additional symptoms which will backup this diagnosis are no cruise control, no trip computer mileage information, both of which are symptoms mine was exhibiting, however all was not as it seemed, because on inspection the wiring loom to the VSS was completely shot! I can only assume heat from the Cats has got to it over the years and all the insulation has literally crumbled and fallen off
So last night I constructed a new loom and ran it to the VSS from connector under the bonnet where the gearbox loom joins the PCM, took it out for a drive and hurrah, I now have trip computer information and cruise control, but still no 4th gear (and no reversing lights, but in honesty I couldn't say for certain whether they worked before) Good news is that the VSS is obviously working fine (good news because although its one of the few parts Ford can still get, its £160)
However I think I may have made a schoolboy error and cut a common +12v feed to the 3\4 Gear solenoid thinking it was the sole feed for the VSS, so rather than splice into it I cut it so now it ONLY feeds the VSS - tonights mission therefore is to reconnect the original wire and see where that gets me.
I have to say though I am loving it, I cannot wait to get home and have a play around with it, to try and diagnose the next problem, I am far more interested in this than I ever was the Fiesta!
|
|
Last Edit: Mar 26, 2016 17:27:05 GMT by ianmk2
|
|
|
ajc91
Part of things
Posts: 164
|
|
|
Very nice hope you get the wiring sorted and it does the trick finding 4th.
|
|
|
|
Del
South East
Posts: 1,448
|
|
|
I'll be keeping an eye on your progress, because my auto 'box has exactly the same problem!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
These are lovely cars,,another on my bucket list!
|
|
Fraud owners club member 1999 Jaguar s type 1993 ford escort
|
|
ianmk2
Part of things
Posts: 116
|
|
|
Hell yeah we have 4th gear! (And reverse lights)
Del I will put a more detailed post up containing everything I've learned about the 4th gear issue later, on my phone right now but had to share the news! Time for a pint
|
|
|
|
ianmk2
Part of things
Posts: 116
|
|
|
Right, the 4th gear issue, i'm not sure how much you already know about these gearboxes, so apologies if i'm preaching to the converted, but this is what I have gleaned from a week's intensive crash course! Also the locations of things I describe are where I have found them on the 24V, I can't speak to whether things might be in different places on other engines, but as the gearbox is essentially the same on all models (bar some extra clutch packs on the more powerful engines) I expect the wiring to be the same also. I hope you are sitting comfortably Firstly, how it works, 1st, 2nd and 3rd shift like any old fashioned automatic box, using manifold vacuum pressure, 4th, however, is controlled by a solenoid which is in the gearbox oil sump. This solenoid doesn't actually shift the gear, it just 'allows' it to engage. In addition there is a 2nd solenoid which controlls the Torque converter lock up function, what this does is lock the torque converter in 3rd and 4th gears above a certain speed, you will notice if you let off or increase the throttle then the revs will rise or fall slightly without any change in speed - this is the torque converter taking up the 'slack' - with the lockup engaged this doesn't happen, the torque converter is effectively eliminated and drive is direct, this improves fuel economy and power delivery, because less is 'wasted' winding up the TC. Odds are if 4th isn't working then this isn't either. So the most common cause of no 4th is the Vehicle Speed sensor (VSS) or associated wiring, this is located at the back of the gearbox on the passenger side (See Photo) This sends a signal to the ECU about vehicle speed. It is worth noting here that this does NOT drive the speedo, the speedo drive is a separate unit on the other side of the gearbox in roughly the same place and depending on model, could be electronic or cable driven. TO my surprise the 24V is actually a mechanical cable driven speedo, but other models could be either. Point being, don't think that because your speedo is working OK the VSS must be OK, that is not its function. Things that depend on an input from the VSS are the trip computer, the cruise control and 4th gear\Torque converter lockup. If it is duff, you won't have any of these. If you have cruise and trip computer but no 4th gear, the problem isn't the VSS, it is more likely wiring or an internal gearbox\solenoid problem. If you have intermittent or odd behaviour from the trip or cruise control, then you will likely have intermittent or odd behavior from 4th gear also. If you suspect that the sensor is good but the signal is intermittent, remove the heat shield above the cats and inspect the wiring, on mine this was the problem, heat had hardened the insulation so it had flaked off and when I stripped some of the loom tape back it was basically just 3 bare wires. You can try and effect a repair if you can strip it back and find good wire to join onto, or do what I did and cut off the plug from the original loom (leaving yourself enough wire to join new ones onto) and run new cables to the "C134" (more on that in a minute) plug in the engine bay. While I am sure repairing the original is possible, it would be incredibly fiddly to do in situ with the exhaust in place, so running new wires is probably easier - it took me about half an hour So, C134, The wiring loom from the gearbox runs into the engine bay and joins the PCM (or ECU if you like) loom in a connector known as C134. It is located on the bulkhead underneath the trim panels, it is an ovalish connector with 12 pins, only 9 of which are used. Afraid I don't have a picture but I can get one if required - again the location may be different on other engines) The 3 wires from the sensor are Brown\Yellow - Signal wire - this carries the pulse from the sensor to the ECU Black\Blue - +12V common feed Solid Brown - Earth To connect the new loom I made I ran it up the side of the engine following the same path as the original, cut the brown and brown\yellow wires on the gearbox side of the loom and soldered my new wires to them. The Black\Blue wire is where I made the mistake, this is a common +12v feed which supplies the reversing lights, 4th\TCC solenoids and the VSS. I cut this and connected my new VSS wire to it - result being my VSS had power but nothing else did, what you need to do is splice onto this wire leaving it intact to supply the rest of the items. It goes without saying, but I am going to say it anyway, to make sure the old wires are not just dangling underneath, because one of these is still going to be +12V from the common feed - so make sure they're taped and well out of the way. If everything with the VSS is OK, but you still have no 4th gear, it is entirely possible the wiring to the solenoids is dodgy, I didn't have to go this far but I would say that getting at it to inspect it would be extremely difficult without at least lowering the gearbox at the back and dropping the exhaust A view of the wiring layout is below, but when in the car the box is quite tight to the tunnel from what I have seen Sensors are still available new from Ford, Finis Part Number 1021991 at a cost of around £150 or there is a breakers in Derby called TopBoss Performance who quoted me £60+VAT for a 2nd hand one. Any more questions let me know and i'll do my best to provide info
|
|
|
|
breng
Part of things
Posts: 223
|
|
|
Is it the A4LD used in the lesser models?
They are'nt the best box and are'nt known for their longevity.
Prices for these are starting to climb now due to people being priced out of mk1's and 2's.
I had a 2.9 ghia X which was lovely - unfortunately we were doing lots of miles and were using up the worlds petrol supplies.
Our family has a 2.4 ghia which has been in the family since 1991.
|
|
|
|
ianmk2
Part of things
Posts: 116
|
|
|
Yes, it is the A4LD and yes it has a pretty bad rep for longevity! Especially on the US forums where they use the same box in Explorers and Rangers
There are 3 variants from what I can see
A4LD - which I believe is entirely mechanically controlled as far as shifting is concerned - used on some early Granada Mk3s A4LDe - which is used in the Cosworth and later model DOHC and 12V - partially electronically controlled for 4th gear selection A4LDE - Used in the frog-eyed Scorpios and is entirely electronically controlled
I am expecting that at some point during my tenure it probably will fail, the car had a brand new gearbox at 80k miles but that still equates to 140k on the new one!
I also think if it does, I will have a crack at rebuilding it myself, in the UK there is a mystique around autoboxes that they're full of voodoo and black magic and must ONLY be touched by auto gearbox specialists, however in the States people rebuild their own fairly routinely and refurb kits are readily available from US ebay
I have read a few guides and as long as you are careful and document each step you take so you get it back together correctly, there is nothing that looks THAT difficult. Its basically replacing a curse word load of o-ring seals, the clutch packs and brake bands.
I mean, whats the worst that can happen..
|
|
|
|
eurogranada
Europe
To tinker or not to tinker, that is the question...
Posts: 2,487
|
|
|
Although this 93/94 model year is my least favorite because of the headlight to bumper transition(I like the 85-92 and 95-up models best) they are such great cars. I have so many fond memories of these... First car to drive, first car to entertain a girl in etc... And the cosworth engines are fine beasts as well, yes they have their shortcomings, but in good nick they are great!
Enjoy the hell out of this car, I keep wanting to put a 91 on the drive myself, but good ones are getting rare!
|
|
|
|
ianmk2
Part of things
Posts: 116
|
|
|
You mean the pre-facelift with the orange side repeaters and non-smoked rear lights etc? I've got to be honest I prefer the clear\smoked, but its strange how tastes change. When I was 17 I wanted a Mk4 Escort as my first car, wouldn't have even looked twice at the Mk3 because it was so 'dated' - now though I think the Mk3 is so much cooler.
I wasn't particularly looking for a Granada initially, I've fancied a Mk2 for a while but a Mk3 wasn't on my radar, I just needed a car that can tow a reasonably large caravan that I use for festivals and car shows. My previous tow car got written off the back end of last year by a friend. I was considering a 735i E38 bimmer from this very parish, but insurance killed it. I couldn't get it on a classic policy with any of the companies I tried and a standard policy, because my no-claims are already in use, was coming out the wrong side of £700.
So I got to thinking what if I could get the best of both worlds, a 'retro' car, because many of the shows I use it for are classic car related, that can also tow, and I can get on classic insurance - next thing I know I'm searching for Granada Cosworth's for sale and the rest is history.
|
|
|
|
|
Ian
Part of things
Posts: 977
|
|
|
I would like a mk3, I have many happy memories of days out in my Dads 2.9 Ghia 4x4. It was the favourite car he owned and did the most miles in, it was big comfy and quite quick at the time. It was bought to go on a European trip but that never happened and it just became his daily driver for about 6 years I think. Tin worm did take the arches in the end and a mk1 mondeo replaced it in the end.
|
|
Last Edit: Mar 3, 2016 14:15:55 GMT by Ian
|
|
ianmk2
Part of things
Posts: 116
|
|
|
Yeah my dad had a K reg 2.0 DOHC, it was a beautiful car, so smooth, it glided over bumps in the road almost silently, no interior trim rattles whatsoever. I have to say these are qualities that mine no longer shares, I guess some of the comfort has been lost with the lower profile tyres and different (?) suspension, and age has induced quite a few interior rattles...nevertheless it still feels like a quality product
It was his first 4 cylinder car after 20-some-odd years of owning 6's and I don't think he was ever really convinced by it. I remember the first time we went on holiday to Dartmouth (as we did every year lol) and he pulled out to overtake something with the caravan, buried his foot and not a great deal happened, he had to abort the manoeuvre. After that all his talk of "modern 4 cylinders being almost as capable as 6's" went aside and the poor Granada fell out of favour somewhat. Then a couple of years later, after a routine coolant change, it blew its head gasket. Now I don't know if it was just coincidence, but its not the only time I've heard of that happening after changing coolant in a DOHC, anyway that was the final straw, he had it repaired then chopped it in for a V6 Mondeo
|
|
Last Edit: Mar 3, 2016 14:48:05 GMT by ianmk2
|
|
Del
South East
Posts: 1,448
|
|
|
I would like a mk3, I have many happy memories of days out in my Dads 2.9 Ghia 4x4. It was the favourite car he owned and did the most miles in, it was big comfy and quite quick at the time. It was bought to go on a European trip but that never happened and it just became his daily driver for about 6 years I think. Tin worm did take the arches in the end and a mk1 mondeo replaced it in the end. Buy mine!
|
|
|
|
Del
South East
Posts: 1,448
|
|
|
Thanks for all the detailed info, Ian. I've always had trip and cruise, so it's almost certainly a wiring issue. Time to find a ramp to get it onto!
|
|
|
|
eurogranada
Europe
To tinker or not to tinker, that is the question...
Posts: 2,487
|
|
|
You mean the pre-facelift with the orange side repeaters and non-smoked rear lights etc? I've got to be honest I prefer the clear\smoked, but its strange how tastes change. When I was 17 I wanted a Mk4 Escort as my first car, wouldn't have even looked twice at the Mk3 because it was so 'dated' - now though I think the Mk3 is so much cooler. I wasn't particularly looking for a Granada initially, I've fancied a Mk2 for a while but a Mk3 wasn't on my radar, I just needed a car that can tow a reasonably large caravan that I use for festivals and car shows. My previous tow car got written off the back end of last year by a friend. I was considering a 735i E38 bimmer from this very parish, but insurance killed it. I couldn't get it on a classic policy with any of the companies I tried and a standard policy, because my no-claims are already in use, was coming out the wrong side of £700. So I got to thinking what if I could get the best of both worlds, a 'retro' car, because many of the shows I use it for are classic car related, that can also tow, and I can get on classic insurance - next thing I know I'm searching for Granada Cosworth's for sale and the rest is history. Yes, that's the one... Although the indicators are available in white as well and the rear lights are interchangeable with the smoked ones as well. To me it's the transition from headlight to bumper that isn't as clean on the 93/94. It has that extra bulge on the stransition piece. The pre-facelifted models have a very tight set of lines in that area, a straight filler piece below the lights and then the bumper. It's not the smoked glass thing that puts me off a bit. I'm also one of those people who really likes the Original ghia lower door trims, giving the car extra body and in most luxury spec often a second colour as well... It's good that we all like different things. But in my mind, the Scorpio's are really one of the nicest cars I've ever experienced. A while ago I was asked to drive a 1986 diesel Scorpio to a dutch meeting as the owner was taking his other car himself and wanted to show off both. I so enjoyed that day. cruising the diesel even felt good. And to hatchback shape of the Mk1 Scorpio is just so eye pleasing to me. Those rear quarters with the way the rear glass connects to them... That heavy bootlid.... I love it all! If it could carry a mobility scooter I would own one right now....
|
|
|
|
ianmk2
Part of things
Posts: 116
|
|
|
New choons installed yesterday. One of the charming things about this car was it came with the original ford head unit and separate in-dash CD player. However I am a bit of a music whore and, especially when in out at festivals, I like to play it at volumes far exceeding those which are deemed safe by people in hi-vis jackets. As well as a tow vehicle it also doubles up as my mobile discotheque. Additionally I couldn't seem to get the stock head unit to hand over the CD it was currently playing and although I have nothing against 'Little Mix' they are quite far removed from my usual pleasure. So onto fitting the trusty old Alpine head unit that has now seen service in no less than 5 cars over the years. I have to say that I really, really rate Alpine units, although it doesn't look very 'period' it must be getting on for 20 years old itself, and it's still as good as the day it was new, CD never skips, still sounds brilliant and thanks to an adapter lead off eBay I can also plug in my generic MP3 device So I removed the original head units, due to some prior reading on the internet I'd stumbled across the information that there was an additional amp behind the wood trim on the passenger side, so I gingerly prised this off too, mindful that at 22 years old it probably isn't at its most flexible Now I am quite averse to cutting original wiring looms and luckily the power side plugged straight into my ISO harness, the speaker wires from the amp however did not. Since I wasn't the first person behind here with a set of wire cutters though (it has an old hands free telephone kit fitted which was also chopped in) I didn't feel too bad about hacking the factory plug off and using crimp on connectors (cringe) - I normally prefer to solder and heat shrink but there was the usual 5mm of slack protruding from the dash to work with so quite tricky A quick test showed that the battery was now flat! The problem is there is so many damn lights! Every time a door is open there is a light in each footwell including the back, a light in the bottom of the door, a light in the back of the door, two main interior lights...no matter after a jump start all was working well (old CD player left in place to fill the hole but obviously no longer functional) Next up was some RF 12 inch subs in the boot to give it that little extra 'something' like the head unit these have seen action in 4/5 cars now and I'm quite surprised they're still alive, but they just keep on keeping on Nestled in the boot amongst other essential "old car stuff" I know subs are a bit...err.."boy racer" but it's my guilty pleasure, I don't ever 'crank it up' when other human beings are within earshot, but when I'm out on my own I do like a bit of bass... Next up is either to tackle the slightly saggy rear suspension, front brakes which although they seem to work fine were an advisory on the MOT, or some new boots, because the tyres look a bit shat
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I had 4 of these new as company cars and used to commute to Germany every week in them, a couple were the later bug eye ones which Looks aside were suberb, the recaro seats in particular were great, even the diesels would do 120mph on the autobahn, the smoke plumes in the headlights of the cars behind looked great!!.
|
|
|
|
ianmk2
Part of things
Posts: 116
|
|
Mar 11, 2016 21:04:07 GMT
|
So I've been using it for work all week and I am starting to have more confidence that it's not going to break every time I take it out, the gearbox has worked faultlessly since repairing the wiring loom, I had planned to drop the box and repair the entire loom because other wires are still in a poor state, but now I'm thinking adopt the "if it ain't broke..." Method
So onto fault #2, rough idling. In fairness the seller was upfront about this and said he suspected it was the inlet manifold gasket, I ordered one but have since concluded that I don't think it is, why? Because it's intermittent, some days it idles fine, other days it doesn't, it's not a misfire as such, it's more of a cough, it definitely feels more fuel mixture related than ignition. I had exactly the same symptoms (tho less severe) on a V6 Mondeo and it was caused by a loose cat on the manifold, since this has its cats under the car and they're new and well sealed I don't think it's the same thing but I do think it's exhaust back pressure related. If it was manifold gaskets leaking it would happen all the time, whereas earlier I started it up at work to come home and the idle was all over the place, stopped it and immediately restarted and it idled perfectly
Which leads me onto the EGR valve, I ordered a code reader during the week and I'm getting code 326 with the engine running, which is apparently due to a sensor detecting low pressure on the EGR circuit. So my theory is that it's getting stuck open sometimes and causing the rough idle, and other times it closes properly and the idle is ok.
So I figure in just going to make a blanking plate and block it off, if anyone knows of a reason I should not do this please speak now or forever hold thy peace.
Another symptom, which I can't quite explain, is that when its idling poorly, and you shift from Park to Reverse or Park to Drive, it really thumps into gear, whereas when it's running fine it's much more gentle, I don't know why this would be, other than its affecting the manifold vacuum to the gearbox
Anyhow, we shall see what tomorrow brings, also a thermostat and oil change on the agenda if that goes well.
|
|
|
|
ianmk2
Part of things
Posts: 116
|
|
Mar 12, 2016 19:54:58 GMT
|
So I got up bright and early to crack on, lovely day for it too, EGR valve first port of call, two 8mm bolts hold it to the side of the manifold, undid them no drama and extracted the gasket as my template for a blanking plate Success Now, what am I going to make a blanking plate out of, I don't really have a 'workshop' knitted out with useful things like sheet metal, let me think about this over a cool can of Coke for a second Think you know where this is going? Well, you're right, probably not the most structurally integral blanking plate ever, but it's more a proof of concept at this stage, I wil make a better one once my mate is back off holiday and can let me use his garage full of useful things again Popped them in and did it back up again, now, as it happens one dos fall into the engine bay while trying to get the bolts in, and I deemed it too difficult to retrieve, so as it turned out there was only one and not one each side of the gasket as I had planned, but hey ho....it was all done and back together within 20 mins and I was dying to try it out But I wanted to do the thermostat first...while the engine was still cool....
|
|
Last Edit: Mar 12, 2016 19:56:41 GMT by ianmk2
|
|
ianmk2
Part of things
Posts: 116
|
|
Mar 12, 2016 20:19:10 GMT
|
....so without any further ado, I set about the thermostat housing three 10mm bolts, quite tricky to get to but nothing too demanding, I remember thinking it would be really bad if , for example, I were to drop a bolt into the engine bay or snap one off, because it has an undertray to stop anything hitting the ground and drilling out a snapped off bolt in that position would be nigh on impossible without taking the radiator and air con rad out So I took extra special care, retained all bolts successfully, got the old thermostat out, nothing visually wrong with it but there rarely is, compared it to the new one, it was a match, so I popped it in, refitted the housing and started it up. Round the front to check all is well, no, all is not well, catastrophically leaking out of the housing, like a fountain erupting from the side of it. Hmm, shut it down, all the bolts are in and tight, maybe it's the wrong stat? So I remove the housing again, it all looks right, except the sealing ring isn't quite as thick as the old one, so without any other option at this stage I refit the old rubber gasket. This is where things start to unravel. First the socket is dropped into the engine bay quickly followed by one of the bolts, damn, under tray off to retrieve those. Get them all back in again and start it up again. Better, but still weeping slightly out of the bottom Maybe if I put an extra tweak on that bottom bolt it will just seal it up....s#%! That's done it...oh wait it was just the ratchet slipping off....no it wasn't, it has actually snapped after all! So off with the housing again, to my absolute relief it has left enough thread poking out to extract it fairly easily, dug out a replacement bolt, cleaned up the seal and the stat housing, refitted again, presto, she is sealed! So did it all achieve what I set out to do, well I'm happy to say yes it did! It idles almost perfectly now, and not only that, it shifts gears much smoother, doesn't thump into drive or reverse as aggressively as it did and is much more willing to shift down when accelerating without having to use kickdown. I think the EGR screwing up the manifold vacuum was affecting the gearbox in more ways than I thought Oh, and the thermostat, well, that worked just fine too All in all, a successful day
|
|
|
|
|